Victor Caratini Landing Spots: 3 best destinations for switch-hitter after $12M Astros stint

Victor Caratini returns to free agency as a clearly defined player. The Houston Astros signed him for two years and $12 million in December 2023 to be a secondary catcher, and that is exactly the role he filled.

He handled a veteran pitching staff, stayed prepared with irregular playing time and provided switch-hitting depth without creating roster pressure.

Around the league, Caratini is viewed as a reliable No. 2 catcher, not a starter and not a developmental project. His value is rooted in game management, familiarity with pitchers and competence on both sides of the plate.

Teams trust him to step in without disrupting routine. His offensive output is modest but predictable, which matters at a position where mistakes cost games.

Any deal for Caratini this offseason might be short-term and role-specific. Clubs looking for catching stability rather than upside are the natural fits. Based on roster needs and usage patterns, these three teams stand out.

---

#1. Chicago Cubs

Chicago Cubs remain a logical landing spot due to their familiarity and the need. The Cubs have previously relied on Victor Caratini and understand his strengths and limitations.

Caratini fits as a secondary catcher who can start once or twice a week, catch specific pitchers and provide switch-hitting depth off the bench. Chicago values preparation and game-calling from its catching group, particularly with a rotation that includes younger arms.

Caratini would not be asked to replace the primary catcher or produce offense in volume, but his role would be controlled and limited.

---

#2. San Diego Padres

The San Diego Padres have cycled through catching options and continue to value experience behind the plate. Victor Caratini fits that need cleanly. He offers steady defense, familiarity with postseason environments and the ability to handle limited starts without affecting performance.

Petco Park does not demand power from catchers and the Padres are comfortable using the position in a timeshare.

Caratini’s switch-hitting allows lineup flexibility, particularly against left-handed pitching. He would serve as a complementary piece rather than a focal point.

---

#3. Milwaukee Brewers

The Milwaukee Brewers consistently prioritize defense and pitcher comfort at catcher. Victor Caratini aligns with that approach. He would slot in as a backup who can start without adjustment and support a pitching staff that often relies on preparation and sequencing.

The Brewers have used similar profiles in the past and tend to avoid long-term commitments at the position.

Caratini’s switch-hitting adds matchup flexibility and his experience working with young pitchers fits the Brewers’ development model.

Edited by nagpaltusharn25