Tyler Warren scouting report: What NFL Draft experts said about Colts tight end

The Indianapolis Colts landed their big fish in the 2025 NFL Draft.

Though it wasn't clear whether the Colts would have a chance to grab Warren in the draft, they got a bit lucky with the Chicago Bears taking Michigan's Colston Loveland with the No. 10 pick.

Despite the major question marks at the quarterback position, the Colts addressed their biggest need of the offseason. The tight end depth chart was lacking a difference-maker in a major way.

After a career of modest production that included 49 receptions for 606 receiving yards and 11 touchdowns over his first four collegiate seasons, Warren broke out in a massive way during the 2024 season. The fifth-year senior recorded 104 receptions for 1,233 yards and eight touchdowns.

In 2024, Warren finished seventh in the Heisman Award voting, won the John Mackey Award and earned a First-Team All-American nod.

Here's what the NFL draft scouting reports said about Warren ahead of the draft:

Tyler Warren scouting report

Dane Brugler, The Athletic (draft guide):

Brugler: "Overall, Warren still has developing to do as a route runner and blocker, but
he is an agile-footed big man who naturally tracks the football with dependable hands and a hunger to create after the catch. He projects as a rookie NFL starter with traditional qualities, as well as the schematic versatility to be a multi-tool weapon for a play caller"

Lance Zierlein, NFL.com

Zierlein: "The ultimate "whatever, whenever" player in the 2025 draft with the size, athleticism and competitive spirit to make good on his intentions. Warren plays with swagger and “best player on the field” energy. He imprints on games with alignment versatility, allowing opportunities for play-callers to stress the defense. Despite his size, he’s quick enough to beat man coverage underneath and plays with good recognition of holes in coverage. He has the ball skills and toughness to win contested catches and withstand punishing contact. He’s very capable as a lead/move blocker but will need a little improvement at sustaining blocks when blocking in-line. Warren can access all three levels of the field but is best served short and intermediate. He possesses elite football character and plays with a confidence that can be contagious. He has a chance to become one of the best tight ends in the league."

Dame Parson, Bleacher Report

Parson: "In all, Tyler Warren is a talented pass catcher who is handling the role as the top offensive option. He should be used as an H-back and flex tight end early in his NFL career until his inline run-blocking improves. Warren's receiving versatility and upside will add another element to an NFL offense and elevate their passing attack."

Ian Cummings, Pro Football Network

Cummings: "Warren is a blue-chip prospect who does everything exceptionally well. He is a fearless competitor, dominant in the run game, and a physical yet savvy receiver with dangerous run-after-the-catch potential. A dominant and instinctive playmaker and his positional versatility makes him a weapon on all three downs, adding to his value at the next level."

Pro Football Focus

PFF: "Warren is a do-everything tight end who any coach would love to input into their offense. He isn't a twitchy or flexible athlete who can unlock the whole route tree, but his versatility is incredibly valuable in the run-and-pass games. He is worthy of a first-round selection."