Red Sox may have rushed Roman Anthony after sophomore slump derails superstar expectations

2 hours ago 3

The Boston Red Sox were able to get a resounding win against the Texas Rangers yesterday, but it only improved them to a 28-39 record, and five games behind the last spot in the AL Wildcard.

Going into this season, they lost a lot of offense when they let Alex Bregman walk in free agency. It seems their gameplan offensively was to bank on their former MLB No. 1 overall prospect Roman Anthony taking the next step, but so far this season, it’s looked like a mistake. 

Last season Anthony looked amazing

Roman Anthony

Imagn Images

When Anthony was called up last season, the whole Boston fandom was excited. He had a slow start to his MLB career, but he started heating up quickly.

He finished the 2025 season as the leadoff hitter, slashing .292/.396/.463/.859 with 18 doubles, a triple, eight home runs, and 32 RBI in 71 games. This performance earned him an eight-year, $130 million extension with the Red Sox.

However he ended the season with a left oblique injury, making him miss the last month of the season, and the Red Sox’s Wild Card appearance. However, it seemed like he would be a superstar bat in the lineup for years to come.

This season he’s had a major sophomore slump

Boston Red Sox outfielder Roman Anthony

Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images

So far this season, however, he’s been anything but a superstar bat. He’s slashed .229/.354/.321/.675 with five doubles, a triple, a home run and five RBI in 30 games. 

He’s also been out since the beginning of May with a partially torn ligament in his right ring finger, which is also unfortunately his throwing hand. Updates about him have been scarce, making it look like he will miss a majority of this season, possibly even all of it. 

Because of this injury and slump, it looks like the Sox jumped the gun once again on a young prospect, which critics have noticed

Another prospect the Sox overestimated was Kristian Campbell, who is struggling in AAA after receiving an eight-year, $60 million extension due to his limited success at the beginning of last season.

Anthony isn’t a bust though

Boston Red Sox outfielder Roman Anthony

Eric Canha-Imagn Images

Anthony’s only played 100 MLB games, so it’s way too early to call him a bust. Plus, in 70 healthy games last season he was amazing; playing that well for almost half a season isn’t a fluke. 

Hopefully, upon his return, he goes back to being his rookie self, and becomes the superstar Boston hopes he can be.

MORE MLB NEWS

Red Sox face major roster decisions as trade deadline forces tough choices on key players

Caleb Durbin’s breakout could save the Red Sox from another major roster mistake

Red Sox’s offensive nightmare could end with Triston Casas’ long-awaited comeback

Read Entire Article