Posthaste: Insurance premiums are surging in Canada — especially in these cities

More expensive claims have driven up auto insurance. Photo by Bruce Edwards/Postmedia

Article content

Article content

Insurance costs are surging in Canada, pushing this household expense up from just a “background bill to a core cost-of-living pressure,” says a new report.

Article content

Article content

Seventy-five per cent of households in the country reported premium increases in auto and home insurance, which have risen faster than wages and inflation, said the Rates.ca report. 

Article content

“Insurance costs are becoming a much more noticeable part of household budgets,” said Daniel Ivans, insurance expert for the comparison site. “A combination of rising claim severity, more expensive vehicles, climate-driven weather losses, and persistent auto theft has pushed premiums higher across many parts of Ontario.”

Article content

Article content

Especially in Toronto, where combined auto and home premiums have climbed from $4,850 in 2022 to $5,693 in 2025. That adds up to about five per cent of the city’s median after‑tax income.

Article content

Article content

“For context, in 2023, the average household spent $8,659 on groceries, meaning the 2025 insurance bill is more than half of a year’s grocery spending,” said the report.

Article content

Premiums for both auto and home insurance are more expensive here because Toronto and its surrounding area is a hot spot for auto thefts, traffic congestion drives up collision and repair costs and the region has suffered a rise in water damage, which is now the leading cause of property claims, said Rates.ca.

Article content

Ottawa, on the other hand, is the most affordable city in the province for insurance costs. Households here pay about three per cent of the city’s median income.

Article content

Torontonians may pay more, but other Ontario cities have experienced steeper increases. From 2022 to 2025, combined premiums soared 37 per cent in Oshawa, 35 per cent in London and 34 per cent in Windsor.

Article content

In 2024 alone, auto premiums spiked 17 per cent and home premiums, 25 per cent in London, Ont.

Article content

Article content

Auto premiums have gone up because of rising costs to repair and buy vehicles, said Rates.ca. The cost of auto parts, maintenance and repairs climbed over 22 per cent from 2019 to 2024 and the price of new vehicles jumped more than 60 per cent and used vehicles over 80 per cent.

Article content

Article content

Dan Park, chief executive Clutch Canada, an online used-car retailer, said higher premiums are affecting auto sales.

Article content

“High premiums deter buyers and can stop deals altogether,” he said. “Particularly among newer or less experienced drivers, some are seeing insurance quotes that rival or even exceed their monthly vehicle finance payment, and in those cases, they’re choosing to walk away from the purchase entirely.”

Article content

Property insurance faces even more pressure, said the study. In 2024 Canada racked up a record $8.5 billion in severe weather damage, 12 times the average in the early 2000s.

Article content

“The past 5 to 10 years have shown just how much home insurance exposure has intensified. The risks are very real, and the industry is feeling it,” said Ivans.

Article content

What are Canadians doing about it?

Article content

The report says two thirds of consumers took action to offset premium increases by shopping around, asking for discounts or removing parts of their coverage.