Mexico, Canada Get Exemption to 10% US Levy But USMCA Risk Looms

07whi)6m5k}srpry(0l[st1h_media_dl_1.png US Commerce Department, Bureau o

Article content

(Bloomberg) — The US Supreme Court’s decision to strike down many of Donald Trump’s tariffs offers some relief to Mexico and Canada, but a much bigger set of risks still hangs over the trade relationship that joins the three countries. 

Article content

The president said in the afternoon the US would impose a 10% levy on foreign goods under a different law. It took several hours before the White House clarified it’s leaving in place an exemption for many goods shipped under the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement.

Article content

Article content

Article content

That exemption means the effective tariff rate for Canada and Mexico will decline. Until the court decision, products that didn’t qualify for the USMCA exemption were taxed at 35% if from Canada and 25% if from Mexico. 

Article content

Article content

For Mexico and Canada, the events provided more proof of the value of the tripartite trade deal, which was signed during Trump’s first term. But the president’s frustration over the court’s decision also raises the risk he may try to radically alter or even blow up USMCA altogether in pursuit of the tariff revenue he wants. 

Article content

The USMCA carve-out exemption allows the US to continue to import oil and other resources from Canada and Mexico tariff-free, and avoids greater disruption in the trade of key manufacturing inputs such as automotive parts. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, when asked about existing exemptions, said the White House was seeking “continuity” with the new tariff order, which will take effect on Feb. 24, the day Trump delivers his State of the Union speech to Congress.

Article content

Both countries were cautious in response to the Supreme Court’s decision. Mexican Economy Minister Marcelo Ebrard said he planned to reach out to his counterparts in Washington and to travel to the US next week to address trade issues. 

Article content

Article content

Dominic LeBlanc, the Canadian minister for US trade, said the justices’ ruling reinforced Canada’s position that tariffs under the US International Emergency Economic Powers Act were “unjustified.” But the government in Ottawa said little else. 

Article content

Punishing tariffs are still in place on steel, aluminum, cars and other categories. And Mexican and Canadian officials know that even if using IEEPA is out, the Trump administration is ready to employ other tactics to gain an edge over them.

Article content

“The president didn’t lose his leverage, he just lost a lever,” said Barry Appleton, a trade lawyer who has advised governments including the Canadian provinces of Ontario and British Columbia. 

Article content

Now, he said, “we’re going to see weaponizations of a variety of different tools that were never, ever conceived of in that way, utilized in that fashion, because the president does not want to go to Congress.”

Article content

‘Huge Arsenal’

Article content

Before Friday’s development, the effective US tariff rate on Canadian goods stood at around 3.7%, according to estimates from Desjardins economist Royce Mendes. For Mexican products, the effective rate was about 4.4%, according to Grupo Financiero Base. It will be slightly lower for both.