James Nnaji’s NCAA return reignites debate and even has Dight Howard wondering

The line between professional basketball and the NCAA is becoming less clear, and Baylor center James Nnaji is the latest example of that change.

Nnaji, a 7-foot center who was selected 31st overall by the Detroit Pistons, surprised many by committing to Baylor for the second half of the season. Even though he was drafted, the NCAA ruled that Nnaji is eligible to play college basketball for four full years. The reason is simple. He never signed a standard NBA contract. Instead, the Nigerian big man spent his time playing overseas, most recently with FC Barcelona, before deciding to return to the college game.

Nnaji’s situation has restarted conversations about NCAA eligibility. Those conversations have even reached some of the biggest names in basketball.

NBA Hall of Famer Dwight Howard recently joked about the idea of returning to college after seeing former professional players explore NCAA opportunities. “I can go get a degree and play college ball,” Howard said. Because Howard went straight from high school to the NBA in 2004, he technically never used his college eligibility.

Wait so I can go get a degree and play college ball ? 😎

Although Howard was clearly joking, his comments point to a growing gray area in college sports. James Nnaji now represents that gray area.

Why Nnaji Is Allowed to Play

The key factor in Nnaji’s case comes down to contracts. While he was drafted by an NBA team, he never signed a full NBA deal. That detail has become very important in recent eligibility decisions.

The NCAA has made it clear that once a player signs a standard NBA contract, their college eligibility ends. However, players who only competed in international leagues, the G League, or on two-way contracts can ask for eligibility to be restored. In recent years, more of those requests have been approved.

Nnaji’s return could make a big difference on the court. His size, strength, and experience playing against professionals give Baylor a major boost in the paint. It also adds depth to an already tough Big 12 conference.

A Growing Trend

Nnaji is not the only player taking this path. Santa Clara guard Thierry Darlan, who spent two seasons in the G League, was cleared to play and is now a regular part of the rotation. Former NBA player Kenny Lofton Jr. has also announced plans to return to college basketball, though his eligibility has not yet been finalized.

These cases have created debate. Some believe college basketball should stay separate from the professional game. Others argue that allowing players to return, especially to earn a degree, fits the NCAA’s focus on education.

Howard’s joke highlights that tension. While no one expects a Hall of Famer to actually suit up for a college team, the fact that it is technically possible shows how much the rules have changed.

What Comes Next

James Nnaji’s return sets another important example. If drafted players who never signed NBA contracts can return to college, more young athletes may view college basketball as a second chance rather than a closed door.

For Baylor, the focus is simple. Nnaji’s impact matters right now. For the NCAA, the bigger question remains. How far can eligibility rules stretch before the meaning of a college athlete starts to change?

As for Dwight Howard, his playing days are over, but his comment struck a nerve. It reflected a real shift in college basketball. One that James Nnaji’s return has clearly brought into focus.

More college basketball news: 

• Rick Pitino reacts to St. John’s opening win
• Ohio State loses point guard commitment
• AJ Dybansta makes debut for BYU
• Jalen Rose on TNT college basketball coverage