Arch Manning trapped in 'superstar or bust' pressure because of his last name

Arch Manning's first full season as the starter at Texas definitely didn’t start smooth. Through the first five weeks of the 2025 season, he was completing under 55% of his throws, and the "bust" chatter started fast for a guy who had been the presumptive No. 1 overall pick in mock drafts before he ever took a college snap.

But he took significant time to settle on the field. He finished the season completing 248 of 404 passes for 3,163 yards, 26 touchdowns, and seven interceptions. He also added 399 yards and 10 more scores on the ground, helping the Longhorns secure a 10-3 record after a big Citrus Bowl win. 

That late surge was enough to put him back at the top of draft boards and enough for him to announce in December that he was passing on the 2026 draft to return to Austin for another year.

That decision is exactly why the pressure isn't going away. Speaking on The Paul Finebaum Show with guest host Cole Cubelic, The Athletic's Stewart Mandel argued that the Longhorns are already getting overhyped in the preseason polls. He added that Manning is carrying a massive burden solely because of his family history.

According to Mandel, expectations would look totally different without the famous last name. "If he had a different last name, people would say, 'Hey, he has a chance to be an All-Conference quarterback this year,' and everybody would be happy about that," Mandel said. Instead, the name on his jersey means that anything less than perfection is seen as a disappointment.

There is a real upgrade happening around Manning heading into 2026, which makes the stakes even higher. Steve Sarkisian has openly praised his quarterback's growth, noting that Manning has improved not only physically but also mentally and in terms of maturity since taking over the job. 

To help him out, Texas went into the portal and added elite talent, including star transfer wideout Cam Coleman from Auburn. The move gives Manning significantly more help than he had during his shaky first year running the offense.

Reports indicate that the university's total roster investment, combining direct revenue-sharing with NIL payouts, has reached approximately $40 million, putting immense pressure on the program to deliver a championship. 

Still, none of that changes the reality Stewart Mandel put on the table. Manning does not get credit for just being a good quarterback. Because of the famous name on his jersey, anything short of being the best player in the country is going to be framed as a disappointment, whether that is fair or not.

More college football news: 

• Ranking SEC football schedules for 2026, from Missouri (hardest) to Alabama (easiest)
• Brendan Sorsby leaving Texas Tech: The fallout on his NFL future, Texas Tech's reputation and more
• Ranking Big Ten football schedules for 2026, from Ohio State (hardest) to Penn State (easiest)
• Best college football betting sites: Top sportsbooks, apps, welcome bonuses, promos, odds and more