Pirates, Reds make surprise trade swapping a pitcher for a hitter

2 hours ago 3

It's not often divisional foes make trades in MLB, but that's what the Pittsburgh Pirates and Cincinnati Reds did on Wednesday.

The Pirates are sending out a pitcher in exchange for a utility player to add to their lineup depth.

The deal, announced by Pittsburgh:

  • Pirates get: INF/OF Tyler Callihan
  • Reds get: RHP Kyle Nicolas

Nicolas was originally a second-round pick by the Miami Marlins in the 2020 MLB Draft from Ball State. He attended high school at powerhouse Massillon Jackson in Ohio.

The 27-year old, 6-foot-3 right-hander has pitched in 86 MLB games, all in relief. He has a 4.68 career ERA.

In 2025, Nicolas had a 4.74 ERA and struck out 8.1 batters per nine innings.

MORE: Reds reportedly sign 12-year old for $2.8 million

He walks 4.9 batters per nine innings in his MLB career, a bit higher than ideal.

Callihan made his MLB debut in 2025.

He was originally a third-round pick in the 2019 MLB Draft out of a high school in the Jacksonville area, taken by the Reds and with Cincinnati until this deal.

Callihan went 1-for-6 in his brief MLB stint in 2025.

MORE: This Mets phenom ate 900 raw eggs in a month to develop his 100 MPH fastball

At Triple-A Louisville, Callihan missed most of the season, but when he played, he had a .303 batting average and .938 OPS. 

His career minor league OPS is .749, likely more in line with his skill level as a potential future utility guy.

This deal is more about depth than anything, but it's still fascinating that the Pirates and Reds convened on such a move.

More MLB news:

Read Entire Article