Oilers’ Connor McDavid, Evan Bouchard’s even-strength struggles threaten early playoff exit

On Tuesday, the Edmonton Oilers face a season-defining moment as they try to avoid elimination in Game 5 of their first-round series against the Anaheim Ducks.

Trailing 3–1, Edmonton has little margin for error against a Ducks team that has translated its regular-season success into a commanding playoff performance.

The Ducks spent much of the year atop the Pacific Division before slipping late in the season. Despite faltering before the playoffs, the Ducks have turned things around and have used their structure and defensive discipline to be particularly effective in neutralizing Edmonton’s high-powered stars.

Through the opening games of the series, Connor McDavid and Evan Bouchard have struggled to generate their usual impact at even strength. 

Following Game 3, both players were tied with Ottawa’s Thomas Chabot for the worst even-strength goal differential among playoff skaters. Now they each sit at minus-4 with just two goals for and six against, according to naturalstattrick.com. Although other players across the league have since dipped that mark below, the lack of improvement from Edmonton’s top contributors remains a major concern.

MORE: The Oilers may be upset about a controversial goal call, but the Ducks are exposing familiar flaws

That drop-off is even more striking when compared to their regular-season production, as Bouchard finished the regular season with a plus-29 even-strength goal differential, tying for 19th-best in the league. McDavid was also among the league’s best with a plus-20 at even-strength goal differential, placing him tied for 20th among forwards alongside five other players.

That level of regular-season effectiveness at five-on-five has not carried into the post-season, and Edmonton’s inability to replicate it has left the club searching for answers. 

Leon Draisaitl has offered a more stable impact at five-on-five. He has been on the ice for six goals against, but has partially balanced that by being on the ice for six even-strength goals by the Oilers. Even so, Edmonton will need a stronger collective effort across the lineup if they want to keep their season alive.

MORE: Oilers Message As They Face Elimination in Game 5 Against Ducks

One surprising positive for Edmonton has been Kasperi Kapanen, who has quietly delivered one of the strongest even-strength performances in the league this post-season. He has been on the ice for six even-strength goals without allowing a single goal against, providing a level of stability the Oilers will need to rely on in Game 5.

With their season hanging in the balance, Edmonton must quickly rediscover its five-on-five form. If that does not happen, Anaheim could eliminate the defending back-to-back Western Conference champions far earlier than anticipated and put additional pressure on an Oilers team determined to stay in Stanley Cup contention and keep its core, including Connor McDavid, firmly committed with only two years remaining on his current contract.

More NHL News

• Wild show the heart of a champion in crucial Game 4 comeback win
• Five young NHL stars we’d like to see play for Team Canada at the World Championship
• 'Not a question of if, it's a question of when,' NHL commissioner Gary Bettman on Winter Classic in Buffalo and more
• Todd McLellan’s blunt season-ending criticism highlights crucial off-season for Red Wings
• Steve Yzerman's job with the Red Wings appears safe, but for how long?