Maple Leafs’ Difficult Season Continues To Fuel Speculation Around Craig Berube's Future

The Toronto Maple Leafs are enduring their most difficult season in nearly a decade, sitting at 27-27-11 and 15th in the Eastern Conference, as their once-reliable playoff streak appears to be in serious jeopardy.

Toronto’s struggles continued Tuesday night with a 3-1 loss to the Montreal Canadiens, extending the Maple Leafs’ losing skid to eight games. The team has not recorded a win since February 3, raising growing concerns among fans and analysts that the franchise’s nine-year run of postseason appearances may soon come to an end.

Highlighting the growing concerns among members of the organization is head coach Craig Berube. 

According to Dave Pagnotta of The Fourth Period, league insiders believe the front office may stay intact, but the coaching staff could face scrutiny. Pagnotta reported Monday that, based on what he has heard from sources, “Brad Treliving is sticking around as GM,” but added that when it comes to head coach Craig Berube, “a change behind the bench will not come as a surprise.”

With frustration mounting, Maple Leafs supporters across social media and fan forums have been debating how the franchise should respond. Suggestions have ranged from trading franchise cornerstones such as Auston Matthews or William Nylander to moving on from GM Brad Treliving. However, the main theory gaining momentum is the possibility of a coaching change.

MORE: Maple Leafs' William Nylander shares depressing feelings on this Toronto season

Berube’s tenure in Toronto has been relatively successful on paper. Since taking over, the Leafs have compiled a 79-53-15 record and last season captured the franchise’s first Atlantic Division title. They also won their second playoff series in two decades under his leadership.

Still, the current downturn has placed Berube at the center of speculation as the organization navigates what many view as a transitional period. Management must decide whether a new voice could help usher the team into its next competitive phase or whether stability behind the bench remains the better long-term approach.

Berube brings significant credentials to the job that got fans excited in the first place, having previously guided the St. Louis Blues to a historic championship run during the 2019 Stanley Cup Finals. That season, the Blues went from a 15-18-4 start and last place in the league standings to a remarkable turnaround that culminated in the franchise’s first Stanley Cup title.

Whether Toronto chooses to stay the course or make a change could define the franchise’s next chapter. The Maple Leafs’ leadership will soon have to determine if Berube is the right coach to guide the club through its retooling or if a new direction behind the bench is needed to spark a future turnaround.

More NHL News

• NHL wild card race watch: Mammoth create separation, Blue Jackets narrow the gap
• Senators' forfeited first-round pick restored; becomes 32nd overall pick
• 2026 NHL Draft Rankings: New names emerge, players shift within top 10 as playoffs approach
• NHL power rankings: Central Division continues to set the pace