Late goal, strong goaltending send Islanders into Christmas break with big win over Devils

Two points and three days of rest were exactly what the Islanders needed for Christmas.

That they got their best all-around effort in five games without Bo Horvat — and the hope is that their leading scorer returns when the Islanders return to action on Saturday against the Rangers — only makes Tuesday’s 2-1 win over the Devils after Adam Pelech’s late winner feel sweeter.

Without Horvat and without Ilya Sorokin — who didn’t dress due to a nagging issue from which he’s expected to return after the Christmas break — the Islanders outplayed New Jersey over 60 pulsating minutes of end-to-end hockey.

There was no issue with getting bodies around the net or generating quality chances; Mat Barzal had a dominant evening and Cal Ritchie had one of the better nights of his young career.

The Islanders’ only problem was that, aside from an unforced error leading to Simon Holmstrom’s second-period goal, Devils netminder Jacob Markstrom was imperious.

New York Islanders right wing Simon Holmstrom (10) celebrates his goal against the New Jersey Devils during the second period at UBS Arena. Dennis Schneidler-Imagn Images

So, despite a 10-2 edge on high-danger chances in the second, the Islanders had just a 1-1 tie to show for it heading into the final 20 minutes, with Brett Pesce’s wrister having gotten New Jersey on the board at 15:35 of the first.

That was how it continued for much of the third: the Islanders all over the Devils, the Islanders unable to score.

David Rittich, when called upon on odd-man rushes against Luke Glendening and Connor Brown, was every bit as good as Markstrom opposite him.

With under five minutes to go, it was the rare 1-1 game that had not only had no penalties committed by either team, but which could have been 4-4.

Rittich, after pushing Timo Meier off him after the Devils forward barged into the net, drew chants of his name from the UBS crowd, a first this season.

Finally, with 1:15 to go in regulation and the game inevitably headed to overtime, the Islanders got something to go.

After Simon Holmstrom missed the net on what looked like a golden chance off the rush, Anders Lee picked the puck off the end wall and fed Adam Pelech, who promptly rifled it into the net for a 2-1 lead.

That was how it stayed after 75 seconds of frantic six-on-five play.

The Islanders were quietly confident they had found something that worked in the second half of Saturday’s 3-2 shootout loss to the Sabres. That was proven correct.

New York Islanders goaltender David Rittich (33) makes a save during the second period when the New York Islanders played the New Jersey Devils Tuesday, December 23, 2025 at UBS Arena in Elmont, NY. Robert Sabo for NY Post

All four lines generated chances and controlled play on Tuesday. Jack Hughes, who has turned UBS Arena into a personal playground numerous times in the past, was held quiet.

There was requisite intensity on the forecheck.

• CHECK OUT THE LATEST NHL STANDINGS AND ISLANDERS STATS

Rittich, making consecutive starts for the first time this season, was solid in net, too, turning aside 27 of 29 shots.

With 44 points in 37 games at the break, the Islanders are sitting above the playoff cutline and far outpacing the expectations of 10 weeks ago.

They won’t get Alexander Romanov or Kyle Palmieri back this season, but if Horvat and Sorokin are both back next week, the Islanders will be primed to make a run at the wide-open Eastern Conference.