How to bet on the 2026 MLB All-Star Game: Odds and best sportsbooks to use for Tuesday

The 96th annual MLB All-Star Game is set for Tuesday evening, and new users looking to place wagers on the action are in the right place.

After Monday night’s sensational Home Run Derby, stars from the American and National Leagues will once again take the field in Philadelphia for the Midsummer Classic at 8 p.m. ET on FOX.

The host Phillies lead all teams with six All-Star representatives on the NL squad, including 2025 MVP Kyle Schwarber. Mike Trout starts in the AL outfield in his 12th All-Star Game.

Even with major draws Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge unavailable, the rosters feature 11 players under 25 and four rookies, highlighting a notable trend toward a youthful league.

Leading the squads from the bench tonight are Dave Roberts of the Dodgers and John Schneider representing the Blue Jays.

Bettors looking for the best All-Star Game opportunities will find numerous sportsbooks to choose from.

The Post delivers a comprehensive guide to these platforms while detailing the leading baseball wagering promotions currently on the market.

Betting on the 2026 MLB All-Star Game

Baseball betting mainly involves moneyline bets, but betting on the MLB All-Star Game differs from regular-season wagering.

Since starters play only about 2-3 innings and all pitchers appear briefly, a different strategy is needed. 

MLB All-Star Game Odds

The National League is slightly favored, with Phillies ace Christopher Sanchez starting. The AL will counter with right-hander Dylan Cease on the mound.

With elite pitching, bettors often target the under of this star-studded contest and for good reason.

MLB All-Star Game betting trends

• The National League has won two of the last three Midsummer Classics
• From 2013 to 2022, the American League won nine consecutive games
• Betting the Under has won in six of the last eight All-Star Games

MLB All-Star Game prop bets

Juan Soto #22 of the New York Mets speaks to Drake Baldwin #30 of the Atlanta Braves and Justin Wrobleski #70 of the Los Angeles Dodgers. Getty Images

Prop betting involves wagers on specific events or scenarios within a game, rather than on the overall winner or total points scored.

Player prop bets are a popular way to bet on the All-Star Game, allowing bettors to diversify their wagers and focus on more specific markets and options without relying on the final result. 

Additionally, game prop markets are available, allowing bets on markets such as extra innings, a no-run first inning, and more. 

Below are some common baseball prop bets:

Team Props

• Team to be the first to score in the game
• Will a run be scored in the first inning?
• Total combined Hits, Runs, and Errors for both teams (over/under)
• First team to reach 3 runs in the game
• Total runs of a specific team (over/under)
• Total Home Runs hit in the game combined (over/under)

Player Props

• Total Hits, Runs, and RBIs (over/under)
• Total Strikeouts (over/under)
• Will a player hit a Home Run? 
• Most Hits, Runs and RBI’s (player vs player)
• Most Strikeouts (pitcher vs pitcher)

Learn all you need to know about MLB Betting

• Read about the Best Baseball Betting Sites
• Learn all about How to Bet on Baseball

Best sportsbook promos to use for the MLB All-Star Game

If you’re looking for the best sportsbook promo offers for tonight’s game, you can find them all right here.

Sportsbooks are offering new users various welcome bonuses when they sign up for an account.

Just click the link on the offers below to get started.

• bet365: Bet $10, Get $150 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
• Fanatics: Get Up To $1,000 Matched in FanCash
• BetMGM: Get up to $1,500 in Bonuses + $50 BetMGM Reward Points
• FanDuel: Bet $5 Daily, Get Up To $1,000 In Bet Resets
• DraftKings: Bet $5, Get $200 in Bonus Bets Instantly
• theScore Bet: Bet Reset up to $1,000

Best prediction markets and promos for the MLB All-Star Game

The growing number of prediction market options also provides additional opportunities to place trades on the ASG.

• New users at Kalshi can secure a trade $10, get $15 bonus when they create a new account.
• Polymarket is offering a deposit of $20, get $50 worth of trades promotion.
• Lastly, those who make any trade on FanDuel Predicts can score a $25 welcome bonus.
• Rising platforms Novig and Prophet X also have enticing welcome bonuses
• Novig: Spend $25, Get $50 in Novig Coins
• Prophet X: Trade $10, Get $20!

Why Trust New York Post Betting

Mike Turay is a sports journalist and editor who closely follows the NBA, NFL, college sports and UFC. He has demonstrated expertise in both NBA and NFL player prop bets for nearly three years. Mike is also highly knowledgeable about the sportsbook offer landscape, frequently trying and reviewing the latest apps and sites.