Ohio State coach Ryan Day took a timeout with 12:53 left in the fourth quarter and the Buckeyes facing third-and-17.
Everybody knew where the ball was going. Freshman quarterback Luke Fahey looked for Heisman Trophy front-runner Jeremiah Smith on a deep fade down the sideline. Nebraska's Jamir Conn broke up the pass, however, and Victor Evans III came down with the interception.
The Huskers – for the first time in 32 games against a ranked opponent – closed out the game. Anthony Colandrea hit Quinn Clark for a 26-yard touchdown to extend the lead to double digits in a 31-28 victory over the Buckeyes.
IT'S PICKED OFF! @HuskerFootball takes over on offense after the tip-drill interception https://t.co/GTJSVv0LFh
— FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) November 21, 2026Ohio State's defense slides against Nebraska
Ohio State trailed 21-14 at halftime despite a brilliant first half from Smith, who had four catches for 117 yards and two TDs. The Huskers, however, had 259 total yards at halftime.
The Buckeyes tied the score with a 14-play, 76-yard drive that took eight minutes and 20 seconds off the clock. Yet the Huskers didn't break this time. Nebraska kicker John Hohl hit a 33-yard field goal with 13:43 left in the fourth quarter. Evans' interception and Colandrea's TD pass followed, but the Buckeyes answered with a TD.
The Huskers had to run 3:49 off the clock, and they did this time. Colandrea's 6-yard run on third-and-5 clinched the victory and touched off a wild celebration at Memorial Stadium.
Anthony Colandrea gets the first down to seal the win vs Ohio State https://t.co/R7IEzuJwn4
— wok (@wokdior) November 21, 2026That effectively eliminated the Buckeyes from Big Ten contention, and defense has been the issue. Ohio State allowed 32.5 points in their last four games – which hasn't helped since the team lost quarterback Julian Sayin to an arm injury in the 19-15 victory against Indiana on Oct. 17.
Colandrea finished 19 of 28 for 200 yards and three TDs. Jamal Rule had 23 carries for 70 yards and a TD – part of a Huskers' rushing attack that had 200 yards on 10.5 yards per carry.
Nebraska made the plays necessary to break a losing streak against ranked opponents that hung over the program – and Rhule. This could be a springboard for the program?
Presure on Ray Day heading into The Game?
The trajectory of Ohio State's season changed when Fahey replaced Sayin at quarterback. The Buckeyes are 1-3 with Fahey as a starter. He finished 16 of 27 for 259 yards, two TDs and an interception. The Buckeyes had just 76 rushing yards and committed two costly turnovers.
Fahey is 94 of 147 (63.9%) for an average of 270 passing yards per game with eight TDs and three interceptions since taking over as the starter. That is not bad for a backup quarterback.
Smith might still win the Heisman Trophy. He finished with six catches for 165 yards, but the star receiver could invite other contenders into the conversation knowing the Buckeyes are all but out of the conference championship picture.
What does this mean for Day, who is now 89-16 as head coach? A hot-seat check seems preposterous knowing the Buckeyes are two years removed from a national championship run, but this is Ohio State's worst regular season since 2011, a 6-7 year under interim coach Luke Fickell. Before that, Ohio State went 8-4 under Jim Tressel in 2004, a season made better by a 37-21 victory against Michigan in the regular-season finale.
The Buckeyes need to beat the Wolverines to get to 8-4, and Day is 2-4 against Ohio State's biggest rival. There is always something riding on The Game. This season could lead to coordinator hot seats for Arthur Smith and perhaps Matt Patricia given the late-season slump, and the program's culture might need a re-examination. Or it could simply be the result of losing 25 players to the NFL Draft over the last two seasons.
