During crises, Democrats get by; Republicans lead

Over Memorial Day weekend, Orange County faced a public safety crisis that could have turned catastrophic.

At the GKN Aerospace facility in Garden Grove, a storage tank holding thousands of gallons of methyl methacrylate began overheating. This was not a minor chemical scare.

It was a volatile, flammable chemical sitting in the middle of a dense urban area.

Homes, schools, businesses and major roads were nearby. Tens of thousands of residents were ordered out of Garden Grove and parts of Stanton, Anaheim, Buena Park, Cypress and Westminster.

Over Memorial Day weekend, Orange County faced a public safety crisis that could have turned catastrophic. AP Photo/Jeff Chiu

The possible outcomes were ugly.

Explosion. Fire. Chemical release. A spill into storm drains or waterways.

That the worst did not happen should not cause anyone to minimize what Orange County was facing. A major industrial hazard threatened working-class neighborhoods in one of California’s most populated regions.

And when the test came, Republican leadership delivered.

As a former public information officer for the Orange County Sheriff’s Department who worked emergency responses in the field and at the county Emergency Operations Center, I have seen firsthand what competent crisis coordination looks like.

The Orange County Sheriff’s Department, under Sheriff Don Barnes, managed Stanton’s full evacuation and coordinated closely with police agencies across the affected cities, including Garden Grove and Anaheim.

As a former public information officer for the Orange County Sheriff’s Department who worked emergency responses in the field and at the county Emergency Operations Center, I have seen firsthand what competent crisis coordination looks like. Getty Images

Supervisor Janet Nguyen helped unify agencies and keep the county response moving in the same direction.

Garden Grove Mayor Stephanie Klopfenstein and Stanton Mayor Dave Shawver were especially visible in keeping residents informed.

But the broader response was unmistakably driven by Republican leadership.

Faulty equipment created serious hurdles. The tank itself was the problem. Valves failed. Cooling and mitigation became more complicated than they should have been.

But once danger was real, the public needed leadership.

It got it.

People were evacuated. Jurisdictions coordinated. Law enforcement held the line. Local officials communicated. State legislators escalated the matter.

Faulty equipment created serious hurdles. The tank itself was the problem. Valves failed. Cooling and mitigation became more complicated than they should have been. AP Photo/Ethan Swope

Republican state Sen. Tony Strickland and Assemblyman Tri Ta called on President Trump to issue a federal emergency declaration. Shortly afterward, it was issued, bringing additional federal resources into the response.

That is how government is supposed to work in a crisis.

You do not hold a seminar. You do not hide behind process. You do not wait for a consultant report.

You act.

That is why this episode matters beyond Garden Grove.

---

Download The California Post App, follow us on social, and subscribe to our newsletters

The contrast is not really Orange County versus Los Angeles. That would be too easy, and not quite right.

The real contrast is Republican crisis leadership versus Democratic crisis management.

To be clear, the fires in Pacific Palisades and Altadena were much larger, deadlier and more complicated than the Garden Grove chemical emergency. They killed people, destroyed neighborhoods and created a rebuilding challenge that will last for years. No serious person should pretend the two events were equal in scale.

But leadership can still be compared.

The Palisades and Altadena fires exposed a Democratic governing culture that prioritizes optics, bureaucracy and political self-protection over accountability.

The real contrast is Republican crisis leadership versus Democratic crisis management. REUTERS

Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass was out of the country when her city faced extreme fire danger. That alone was a stunning failure of judgment.

Residents who lost homes deserved urgency. They deserved straight answers. They deserved visible leadership. Instead, they got delays, confusion, finger-pointing and bureaucracy.

When reporting showed that criticism of the city’s fire response had been softened or removed, it confirmed what many already suspected. The political class was protecting itself.

That is the Democratic model in too many California crises.

Manage the narrative first. Protect the institution second. Help the public somewhere down the list.

Orange County’s Republican-led response offered a different model.

It was not perfect. No emergency response ever is.

But it was serious. It was coordinated. It was visible. It was focused on immediate public safety.

Strickland and Ta did not sit around waiting for someone else to ask Washington for help. They pushed.

Meanwhile, Gov. Gavin Newsom had no public presence over the holiday weekend. He issued the necessary emergency declaration — and otherwise went dark.

Manage the narrative first. Protect the institution second. Help the public somewhere down the list. AP Photo/Jill Connelly

Showing up is not everything. In a major public safety crisis, it is not nothing.

California is not going to run out of crises. Fires, floods, earthquakes, chemical incidents, homelessness, crime and collapsing infrastructure are now part of daily life in this state.

Voters should stop judging politicians by speeches, slogans and press conferences. They should judge them by performance.

When the chemical tank crisis hit Orange County, Republican leaders acted like public safety was their first responsibility. When the Palisades and Altadena fires tested Democratic leadership, too many officials seemed more focused on managing the politics of failure than fixing the failure itself.

This state has serious problems. It needs serious management.

And after years of one-party Democratic control, voters should ask a very simple question:

If Democrats were the answer, wouldn’t California look a lot better by now?

Jon Fleischman, a longtime strategist in California politics, writes at SoDoesItMatter.com.