China and Oil Shocks Push Climate Down Pacific Islands’ Agenda

Article content

(Bloomberg) — For years, the Pacific islands managed something remarkable — some of the smallest nations in the world persuaded their larger, more powerful allies that climate change was the region’s defining security challenge and pushed them to act.

Article content

Now, that hard-won focus is being tested as strategic competition with China and the impact of the Iran war on fuel supplies increasingly dominate the region’s diplomatic agenda.

Article content

Article content

At the Pacific Islands Forum Foreign Ministers’ meeting in Fiji last week, China’s ballistic missile test in the Pacific last month and the Middle East conflict were the issues at the forefront of discussions. Papua New Guinea Foreign Minister Justin Tkatchenko said on the sidelines of the meeting that climate change was no longer the region’s priority.

Article content

Article content

“In this situation we’re now facing with war all around the world, of course, it takes more priority than climate change,” he said. “Climate change has been put on the outer, really, at this point of time when we’re more interested in what oil we can get and how much we can get of it.”

Article content

Article content

Anna Powles, an associate professor at Massey University’s Centre for Defence and Security Studies in New Zealand’s capital Wellington, said many Pacific leaders and organizations are concerned that geopolitical competition is overshadowing Pacific priorities, namely climate change.

Article content

“There’s a frustration that clearly identified Pacific priorities, like climate change, are not getting the same level of attention that strategic competition is getting,” she said.

Article content

Melanie Pill, honorary senior lecturer at the Australian National University and the founder of independent consultancy the Climate Project, said China’s missile test had been designed to intimidate and undermine the Pacific. 

Article content

“It definitely distracts from the single most defining issue for the Pacific and for the whole world,” she said. “I don’t think it sets back the importance of addressing the impact of climate change in the Pacific, but it might not progress at the same pace.”

Article content

Article content

Diplomatic Response

Article content

China’s growing influence in the Pacific has spurred an unprecedented diplomatic response.

Article content

Australia is forging a number of treaties and agreements with Pacific nations in an attempt to shore up its influence and block Chinese advances. Canberra sealed a cooperation deal with Vanuatu in June, signed a new security pact with Fiji and has inked security and policing agreements with Papua New Guinea and Tuvalu. 

Article content

New Zealand last year paused development funding to the Cook Islands after the tiny South Pacific nation signed agreements with China without the expected level of consultation. Their relationship has since thawed, with the two countries signing a defense and security declaration in April.

Article content

Powles said Pacific governments are trying to extract the benefits of closer ties with larger powers.

Article content

“These agreements do provide benefits such as increased maritime surveillance, funding to combat organized crime and stronger bilateral relationships,” she said. While Pacific countries do try to use these negotiations to advance their own priorities, the imbalance in power limits how much leverage they have on matters such as climate change, Powles added.