Torso of a man in a suit and tie descending stairs

Many managers say you’re better of working from the office. They argue it’s good for productivity, collaboration, and company culture. But what if the real reason is actually not about work at all?

What if your boss just wants to feel powerful?

A new study from the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School suggests that leaders with stronger narcissistic tendencies are more likely to resist remote work. And the reason may have less to do with how well employees work and more to do with how much control their bosses have over them.

The Bigger the Ego, the Stronger the Resistance

For years, companies and managers had been telling us that you simply can’t have people working from home. Then COVID-19 came and, as it turns out, quite a lot of jobs could be done just fine from home.

This was a revelation, but not everyone was thrilled to see that people could work from home just fine.

The research, published in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, wanted to see what kind of bosses were more opposed to remote work. Marissa Shandell, Courtney Elliott, and organizational psychologist Adam Grant started by looking at the top of corporate America: Fortune 500 CEOs.

They examined 259 executives and their public statements about remote work during the early pandemic, from March 2020 to May 2021.

Since you can’t just ask the bosses of the world’s biggest companies to come and give personality tests, researchers used several established, indirect indicators. These included the size of the CEO’s photograph in annual reports, the size of their signature, and how much they were paid compared with their company’s second-highest-paid executive.

The logic is that executives with stronger narcissistic tendencies are more likely to make themselves unusually prominent in corporate communications and command disproportionately high compensation. It’s not perfect, but it can be an indicator of narcissistic tendencies.

The researchers then compared these measures with what CEOs had said about working from home.

Worship me at the altar

The study, titled “Worship me at the altar: Why narcissistic leaders resist remote work” revealed a clear pattern. CEOs who scored higher on narcissism expressed stronger resistance to remote work and offered a wider range of objections to it.

They raised concerns about productivity, innovation, collaboration, training, workplace culture, and employee well-being. Of course, those concerns can be legitimate. But the researchers suspected something else was happening beneath the business arguments.

To investigate, researchers conducted a second study, surveying 359 leaders across different levels of management over three separate waves. Rather than relying on indirect indicators, they measured narcissistic traits and motivations through questionnaires.

“Narcissism was the only trait that we found that consistently predicted resistance to remote work,” Shandell said. “Leaders who had narcissistic qualities were the most likely to resist remote work, and that was driven by their desire for power and status.”

Remote work takes away something that narcissistic bosses crave

Think about the traditional office.

The boss occupies the corner office. Employees gather around the conference table. A manager can summon someone for a meeting, walk past their desk, or interrupt their work with a question.

There are countless opportunities to signal authority. Who speaks first? Who interrupts? Who receives attention when they enter the room?

Now imagine that same boss on Zoom.

Suddenly, they’re another rectangle on a screen. Their employees can mute themselves, switch off their cameras, or answer messages when convenient. A grand office and an imposing physical presence carry little weight in a video meeting.

For most managers, these are simply differences in how work gets done. They bring some challenges and some practical problems, but all in all, it’s just another day.

For a narcissistic leader, they may feel like threats.

Psychologists distinguish between two related motivations: power, the desire to control other people, and status, the desire to earn their admiration and recognition.

People with stronger narcissistic traits tend to place unusually high importance on both. A boss who thrives on commanding attention may find a physical office more psychologically rewarding than an efficient remote team.

Yet another study shows the same thing

The researchers tested this explanation in a third study involving 546 leaders.

They randomly assigned participants to an exercise designed to temporarily heighten narcissistic thinking or to a control condition. They then measured attitudes toward remote work.

Those prompted into a more narcissistic mindset reported greater resistance to remote work.

On a seven-point scale, their average resistance score was 3.69, compared with 3.40 in the control group. The difference was modest, but statistically significant.

Importantly, the experiment linked this increase to a heightened desire for power. The evidence for status as the explanation was weaker. In other words, the most compelling finding wasn’t necessarily that narcissistic bosses need admiration. It was that they want control.

But isn’t working from the office just better?

Executives have often defended office mandates by appealing to teamwork, spontaneous creativity, mentoring, and company culture.

And those arguments aren’t inherently unreasonable. Some jobs demand physical presence. New employees may benefit from face-to-face mentorship, and certain kinds of collaboration can be easier in person.

But studies challenge the idea that working from the office guarantees better performance.

For example, a 2024 randomized trial published in Nature involving employees at a technology company found that a hybrid arrangement, with employees working from home two days per week, reduced resignations by roughly one-third without harming measured performance or promotions.

In a landmark 2015 experiment, researchers found that call-centre employees working from home were 13% more productive than their office-based colleagues, while employee turnover fell by roughly half. A separate study of US patent examiners found that allowing employees to work from anywhere increased output by 4.4%, without compromising work quality. More recently, an analysis of S&P 500 companies found that return-to-office mandates were associated with declining employee satisfaction but no statistically significant improvement in financial performance.

Instead, the Wharton study suggests the person making the decision may have motivations that have little to do with the company’s interests.

The researchers suggest that organizations should consider involving a broader range of people in decisions about workplace flexibility, rather than leaving such choices entirely to leaders whose personal motivations may influence the outcome.

After all, the question shouldn’t be whether employees are physically present to make their managers feel powerful.

It should be whether they’re doing their jobs well.