Will Mamdani only offer four years of ‘Potemkin socialism’ like his grocery fiasco?

1 hour ago 3
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announces La Marqueta in East Harlem as the first site selected for the city's public grocery store initiative. Mayor Zohran Mamdani announces La Marqueta in East Harlem as the first site selected for the city's public grocery store initiative. Luiz Rampelotto/ZUMA / SplashNew

Zohran Mamdani’s “city-run groceries” gambit was always mostly symbolic — even he doesn’t pretend one-store-per-borough will be more than proof of concept — but it’s fast becoming a symbol and sign of how hollow his whole mayoralty could prove.

Last week he at long last unveiled the plan for the first store: He says it will cost $30 million and take nearly three years to build.

That’s 40% of what the mayor had said five groceries would cost — and many times what the private sector spends to build a grocery store in just a few months.

As Anthony Pena, president of the National Supermarket Association, told The Post: “Even a high end, gourmet store in the middle of Manhattan wouldn’t cost that much to build.”

(It’ll get worse, too: New York public projects never cost less or finish faster than the initial estimate — they’re almost always over-budget and long-delayed: Don’t bet the store opens before Mamdani’s running for re-election in 2029.)

Worse yet, Mamdani’s already tossed the main point of the exercise — offering food at affordable prices — into the dumpster: Only a core basket of goods will be particularly cheap.

Actually, two main points: Rather than boost food access in under-served areas, this stores going up in a ’hood with at least five others.

A “Potemkin village” is a fake-front display slapped over a grim reality; the grocery debacle suggests Mamdani is offering his fans Potemkin socialism.

That is: “Achievements” posed for TikTok or Instagram so the mayor can wow his affluent, transplant-heavy voter base — while completely failing to make good on his inaugural-speech vow to deliver “safety, affordability, and abundance.”

It’s already a pattern:

  • His tax-the-rich vows of income- and corporate-tax hikes have dwindled down to a surtax on pieds-a-terre — a loser for the city overall, but also not the mass-redistribution of a proper socialist.
  • His Department of Community Safety will no longer displace the NYPD on many calls; it’s just handing high-paying jobs to a couple of comrades.
  • Even his rent freeze will disappoint his base, since it covers only rent-stabilized units — and will likely push up market-rate rents.

Get opinions and commentary from our columnists

Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter!

Thanks for signing up!

He’s even cut public-library funding as a bargaining chip in budget negotiations.

Yes, we’re pleased by some of this, especially his retreats from undermining public safety — but Mamdani didn’t run for mayor to make the New York Post happy.

Maybe it’ll work for him, even if his old Democratic Socialist buddies decide he’s a sellout.

And don’t get us wrong: We see his policies doing vast damage, from his corrosive DEI push to his endless tax-hike crusade to his undermining of the NYPD.

But he’s doing nothing to meaningfully better New Yorkers’ lives, nor to ensure that the city he pretends to love has a future.  

And no amount of theater-kid videos, even ones staged with billions in city funds, can change that.

Read Entire Article