Like the grown-up I am with my entirely respectable grown-up priorities in life, I drove an hour away from my small rural town to stay up past midnight at a marathon cinema screening of Heated Rivalry. Continuing my entirely respectable life choices, I decided to follow up my viewing of the Horny Hockey Show the next day with an early morning viewing of the Horny Basket Film (also known as Wicker). As an avid reader of quirky fantasy romance, I was clearly the target audience for a film in which Olivia Colman (the “Fisherwoman”) asks Peter Dinklage (the “Basketmaker”) to craft her a husband, thus resulting in her marriage to Alexander Skarsgård in the form of a Wicker Man. Almost immediately, the Fisherwoman and the Wicker Husband set about mutually satisfying marital activities that result in a broken bed and a rather scandalized local community.
Despite the entertaining and attention-grabbing premise, Wicker offers quite a poignant reflection on intimacy and human relationships. In contrast to the other members of the town, the Fisherwoman and her Wicker Husband show genuine love and respect for one another. This is highlighted beautifully in the scene where Colman’s character first introduces her new husband publicly at a town wedding. The two dance together (despite the Fisherwoman protesting that she does not really know the dance) in a show of graceful partnership. The steps performed by the other couples are rigid, brusque, and almost seem combative.
On the surface, Wicker offers the audience a sexy fairy tale romance. Looking at it more deeply, however, the story subverts the simplicity of the fairy tale. The dynamic of the lonely Fisherwoman and her doting Wicker Husband—in both their joy and their angst—invite us to consider how much risk goes into loving someone else and allowing ourselves to be loved in turn. True love will always come with uncertainty, but the Wicker Husband reminds us such uncertainty is what makes love worth having.
It is worth noting that Wicker is based on a bittersweet short story, “The Wicker Husband” by Ursula Wills; one of the great strengths of the film is the way in which it stays true to the fairy tale framing of the original story. This is particularly noticeable with language used in both the story and the film that echoes the repetitive pattern of fairy tales. When the Wicker Husband appears in the village, he goes in turn to the tailor, the shoe maker, and the innkeeper asking for their respective items “for I am being married tomorrow”—he cannot show up at the chapel without a proper suit, or shoes, or a drink to celebrate his coming marriage. Likewise, as the Wicker Husband notices needed repairs in the Fisherwoman’s cottage, he makes observations like “the roof is leaking, bring me a hammer and I will fix it” or “the bed is broken (again!) bring me a hammer and I will fix it.”
In both the film and the story, the use of such fairy-tale language lures us into seeing the figures in the tale—from the Wicker Husband to the Fisherwoman (simply “the ugly girl” in Wills’ story) or the Tailor’s Wife—as caricatures, rather than fully fleshed out characters. It is this superficiality itself, however, that Wills plays with in her deceptively short and simple story about a lonely girl looking for a husband. As in the film, upon seeing the way the Wicker Husband dotes on his wife, the townspeople fall into immediate judgment. The women become jealous of the attention shown to the undeserving “ugly girl” while their husbands remain indifferent; the husbands resent how the Wicker Husband reveals their own marital inadequacies. As much as Wills’ story is a quirky, often funny, fairy tale, it has an undoubtedly darker edge. As happens in the film, the scheming Tailor’s Wife sows the seeds of doubt about the Wicker Husband’s infidelity. The uncertainty eats away at the Ugly Girl until in a fit of distress she sets fire to her Wicker Husband. While the Ugly Girl of Wills’ story does eventually realize her failure to trust and return to her restored Wicker Husband, there is no certainty of a happily ever after (or even much of a happy for now). Despite the superficial framing of the characters in her story, Wills offers a poignant reflection on human relationships. We all have much going on beneath the surface, and (as we see on a title card offered up by the film) it is often much easier to believe the bad rather than the good.
Wicker effectively takes these thematic nuggets planted by Wills and translates them beyond a cautionary tale into an effective commentary on the nature of genuine love and intimacy. In yet another example of the deceptively straightforward storytelling, the film brings a clearly gendered component to the nameless identities of the townspeople. Not only is Tailor’s Wife the wife of the Tailor, but before her marriage she was Doctor’s Daughter, always identified by her relationships to a man. A notable (and again rather unsubtle) feature of the film universe is the collar women wear during their marriage ceremony to bind them to obedience. Olivia Colman’s character is unique in being the Fisherwoman. Having been orphaned young, she has no man to define her.
While it is easy to focus specifically on the gendered dynamics of the world of Wicker, the film more pointedly plays with the transactional nature of all relationships within its world. The first interactions we see among any of the characters involve buying and selling; one character tells another early on that it is “lovely transacting with you.” It is against this background that the film builds the fascinating relationship of the Fisherwoman and her Wicker Husband, which is ostensibly the most transactional relationship. The Fisherwoman literally buys her Wicker Husband from Peter Dinklage’s Basketmaker. Nevertheless, their marriage becomes the most substantive one in the film. The key to their connection—both when it threatens to fall apart and when it is restored—is mutual trust and freedom.
At this point, it is necessary to discuss Peter Dinklage’s Basketmaker, the first character in the film who looks beneath the surfaces of those in the town. He immediately recognizes the shallowness of the Tailor’s Wife and the kindness of Colman’s Fisherwoman. While the Fisherwoman does offer monetary compensation to the Basketmaker for her Wicker Husband, it is also clear the Basketmaker feels for the Fisherwoman’s loneliness and agrees to the challenge of making a husband as an act of kindness. As he begins to imagine the process of weaving together material for the Wicker Husband, the Basketmaker notes specifically that the man must have free will. This fact is reiterated in the film’s third act when the Fisherwoman has given in to her doubts of her Wicker Husband’s fidelity and laments that he could have never truly loved her in the first place. Quite contrary to the film’s “horny basket movie” reputation, the Basketmaker declares bluntly that he did not make the woman “a piece of fuckable furniture.”
Throughout the film, it is this very non-transactional dynamic that sets the marriage of the Fisherwoman and the Wicker Husband apart from the rest of the town. In one particularly notable conversation, the Wicker Husband joins the other men of the town at the inn. The Baker, whose wife is quite fascinated by the ardor the Wicker Husband shows the Fisherwoman, begs the Wicker Husband to sleep with his wife. Although the Baker confesses to love his wife, he is at a loss for how to secure her affection. The men of the town tease the Wicker Husband for being “forced” to make all the repairs to the Fisherwoman’s home. To this, the Wicker Husband can only reply that he does such jobs because it makes his wife happy. Consequently, the bed then requires further repairs.
Perhaps we might call the dynamic we see at work in the marriage of the Fisherwoman and her Wicker Husband a kind of grace that goes beyond merely romantic love. This notion of grace offers an intriguing way of understanding the strange Wicker Child who appears in the film’s final act. Distressed by her own lackluster marriage (and her husband’s accidental death when he tries to replicate the Wicker Husband’s handyman ways), a young woman seeks a child from the Basketmaker in the same way the Fisherwoman acquired her husband. Notably, the young woman offers sexual advances if her coin is not enough for the Basketmaker to take the job (the Basketmaker declines). But once she has her Wicker Child, the young woman continues to descend into despair, and the child languishes as well. Genuine love cannot, in fact, be bought and sold.
Later, after the Wicker Child is used to drive a wedge between the Fisherwoman and the Wicker Husband, the Fisherwoman finds the child alone. Seemingly without reason, the Fisherwoman chooses to care for the Child, a creature that has brought her nothing but pain. The Fisherwoman has nothing to gain from this care. Her act of grace is arguably the most freely given act of love in a world where human relationship is framed entirely as transaction. I like to think it is seeing the Fisherwoman with the child that convinces the Basketmaker to encourage the Fisherwoman to seek reconciliation with her Wicker Husband.
Unlike Wills’ story, the film offers a more explicit happy ending for Fisherwoman and the Wicker Husband. Although his body is burnt, and there is rot in his wood that will eventually take him over, the Wicker Husband and the Fisherwoman embrace the future that remains for them together. They do so, however, in terms of mutual freedom and respect. The rest of the townspeople end the firm with a poetically just reward. Promised the prize of a “Wicker Woman” by the Basketmaker, they each offer a gift in hopes to win the woman for themselves and their own differing agendas. In the end, though, the winning butcher gains a woman made of blackthorns. As the butcher cries in agony from his new wife’s embrace, the Wicker Husband and the Fisherwoman ride into the sunset with the Basketmaker and their Wicker Child. Perhaps they cannot be assured of an uncomplicated fairy tale happy ending, but that uncertainty is what makes their genuine love possible.
