The Rams' defense had some impressive moments on "Monday Night Football," holding Josh Allen to just four completions in the first half, and they looked to have another when James Cook fumbled in the third quarter.
There was no doubt surrounding the fumble, as the ball was cleanly punched out of Cook's grasp, but the recovery was a point of contention.
The Rams were initially ruled to have recovered the fumble, only for the call on the field to be reversed "after discussion" and evidently without a video review.
Here's a look at the critical sequence that kept the ball in the hands of the Bills.
MORE: The cases for and against a Bills-Rams Super Bowl
Why refs reversed Rams' fumble recovery
Within seconds of approaching the pile of Rams and Bills all trying to get ahold of the ball fumbled by Cook, an official ruled Los Angeles had recovered. That would've given the Rams possession near midfield with the lead in hand.
Who recovered this fumble? It appears that Buffalo might've had it for a brief second but then the Rams ended up with it. Refs ruled it Rams ball on the field but then quickly reversed that calling and kept it Bills ball https://t.co/QQ2DlIpRCy
— Rate the Refs (@Rate_the_Refs) October 13, 2026Instead, officials quickly got together and reversed the on-field decision "after discussion," seemingly without any kind of video review.
Dion Dawkins walked away with the football, but replay of the swarm of players gunning for the ball didn't appear to show a clear recovery. Had the officials stuck with the call on the field and then reviewed the play with replay, it's possible no conclusive evidence either way would've forced them to stick with the call on the field: Rams ball.
The officials instead had a discussion and quickly ruled that the Bills recovered Cook's fumble. NFL officials can pick up a flag or quickly change the call on the field after an official confers with other officials, but the decision to instantly change the call without reviewing it confused many fans.
The Bills, meanwhile, went down the field and put six points on the board to regain the lead.