The Mets have consistently ranked right alongside the Dodgers as the two teams with the highest payrolls since Steve Cohen purchased the team in 2020, but the results for those two franchises could not be more different.

L.A. won back-to-back championships in 2024 and 2025 before winning 100 games in 2026. The Mets reached the NLCS in 2024, but they faceplanted in the second half of 2025 and missed the postseason before unraveling even more in 2026.

It takes more than money to win in baseball, but money certainly helps. The Mets threw more money at their problems on Sunday, when they reportedly agreed to a nine-year, $450 million deal with two-time Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal.

Skubal unquestionably makes the Mets better today, but the contract is set to last through his age-38 season. Given the fragility of pitchers, that's a sizable risk for New York.

How much of a risk? Here's what history tells us.

MORE: Highest-paid MLB players after Tarik Skubal signing

The history of lucrative, long-term pitcher contracts

Skubal's contract is the 21st in MLB history worth at least $160 million for a pitcher; every deal has spanned at least five years. Take any set of 20 contracts in any sport, at any position, and the outcomes won't be uniform. There will be good, there will be bad and there will be in-between.

That's no exception for MLB pitchers, but the risk rate is particularly high.

Here's a breakdown of each of the 20 contracts that came before Skubal and how they turned out.

The good

PitcherContractTeamContract began
Yoshinobu Yamamoto12yr/$325MDodgers2024
Gerrit Cole9yr/$324MYankees2020
Clayton Kershaw7yr/$215MDodgers2014
Max Scherzer7yr/$210MNationals2015
Justin Verlander7yr/$180MTigers2013
Cole Hamels7yr/$173MPhillies2013
CC Sabathia7yr/$161MYankees2009

It is possible to give a pitcher a massive contract and be able to call it a success. These seven prove it.

Yoshinobu Yamamoto still has nine years remaining on his deal, so having some hesitance to call it a success is understandable, but the average annual value ($25 million) is so low and the success rate through three years (two top-5 Cy Young finishes, two championships) is so high that it's tracking to be a massive win for the Dodgers.

Seven-year deals for Justin Verlander and Clayton Kershaw were successful, even if some of their best seasons came before the deals — for the Tigers, some of Verlander's finest work came after he was traded to the Astros. Both win Cy Young Awards after signing the deals.

Gerrit Cole missed a season due to Tommy John Surgery but has otherwise been stellar seven years into a nine-year pact, while CC Sabathia sharply tailed off in the final three years of what would've been his seven-year deal (he agreed to a reworked contract in 2011) but was a legitimate ace over the first four and anchored a World Series-winning rotation.

Cole Hamels might not have been a Cy Young contender during much of his contract, but he remained a top-of-the-rotation arm for the bulk of the deal.

Perhaps the best lucrative pitching deal in MLB history belongs to Max Scherzer, who was an ace wire-to-wire with two Cy Young Awards and a World Series win during his deal with the Nationals.

MORE: Tracking MLB signings, trades, rumors from 2026 offseason

The so-so

PitcherContractTeamContract began
Zack Greinke6yr/$206.5MDiamondbacks2016
Felix Hernandez7yr/$175MMariners2013
Stephen Strasburg7yr/$175MNationals2017
Carlos Rodon6yr/$162MYankees2023

These contracts weren't flops, but they generally weren't what the team giving them out envisioned.

Zack Greinke struggled in year one with the Diamondbacks. While he was much better in 2017 and 2018, Arizona traded Greinke midway through the fourth season and only got an NLDS appearance out of the pact.

Felix Hernandez continued to pitch like an ace over the first three years of his seven-year extension with the Mariners and was fine in the fourth season, but he unraveled in years 5-7.

Stephen Strasburg is an interesting case: this isn't the disastrous deal he signed when he opted-out in 2019, so he was a front-of-the-rotation arm for the first three years and famously powered Washington to a championship in year three. Over what would've been the final four years, however, Strasburg was basically absent due to shoulder issues. For what he did in 2019, the deal can't be called a failure.

The Yankees' deal for Carlos Rodon has actually aged well, but not well enough to make a call one way another. A disastrous first season gave way to a middling second season, but Rodon has been much more ace-like over the last two years. After injuries limited him to 16 starts in 2026, though, it's not enough to say New York won the deal.

MORE: All details known about Tarik Skubal's huge Mets contract

The jury's out

PitcherContractTeamContract began
Max Fried8yr/$218MYankees2025
Blake Snell5yr/$182MDodgers2025
Dylan Cease7yr/$175MBlue Jays2026
Garrett Crochet6yr/$170MRed Sox2026

These contracts are all too fresh to make a declaration one way or another.

Max Fried's deal certainly looks like a success for the Yankees, but much can change with six years remaining. The Dodgers got a World Series win out of Blake Snell's first season, but he's made just 20 starts over two years.

Dylan Cease's first season gives the indication that the Blue Jays will be satisfied with his deal, though the same standard that applies to Fried applies here. The first season of Garrett Crochet's deal (signed in 2025 but took effect in 2026) was a lost one due to shoulder injuries, but with five years remaining, he can still get the benefit of the doubt.

MORE: Pete Crow-Armstrong headlines SN's 2026 MLB award winners

The bad

PitcherContractTeamContract began
Stephen Strasburg7yr/$245MNationals2020
David Price7yr/$217MRed Sox2016
Corbin Burnes6yr/$210MDiamondbacks2025
Jacob deGrom5yr/$185MRangers2023
Aaron Nola7yr/$172MPhillies2024

Here's the good news for the Mets: of the 16 that are far enough along to make a call, only five can be characterized as a failure.

Stephen Strasburg's deal speaks for itself, as he made a grand total of eight starts after signing it. David Price was much healthier, but he was at no point an ace with the Red Sox even if he contributed positively on occasion.

Corbin Burnes is only two years into his deal with the Diamondbacks, but both were effectively lost to Tommy John Surgery. For now, it's a miss for Arizona.

The Rangers technically won a World Series with Jacob deGrom, but he effectively lost his first two seasons to Tommy John Surgery. After a terrific 2025, deGrom was more inconsistent in 2026, and his salary weighed Texas down after he declined a deadline trade to Atlanta.

The Phillies undoubtedly regret re-signing Aaron Nola ahead of 2024, as he has a 5.14 ERA over the last two seasons and still has four years left on his deal.

MORE: Ranking the best free agents available in 2026 MLB offseason