When it comes to digital romances, BioWare was one of the best to ever do it. Though the studio wasn’t the first to implement romanceable companions, BioWare set the example for what a fulfilling digital romance could be. Its work made the right people mad, with Mass Effect’s same-sex relationships generating sensational segments on national TV networks way back in 2007. 

BioWare’s dedication to inclusion resulted in some of the best AAA examples of queer love, kink dynamics, and gender expression in relationships, as well as how trauma informs romance and sex, and even senior love. At other times, BioWare romances were just fun little one-offs with no strings attached because relationships are like that sometimes in real life, too. They gave us some of the funniest lines in video game romance and some of the most heartbreaking, and all of them truly memorable.

With BioWare now gone, other studios have stepped in to carry the love-torch, but like your first kiss, you never forget your first BioWare romance. Here are the studio’s best.

BioWareScreenshot: BioWare

Garrus

By any objective estimation, Garrus Vakarian should not be appealing to women. He is a 6-foot-plus armored bird lizard with a mouth that reminds people of a certain age of the movie Tremors, but he remains universally at the top of any Mass Effect enjoyer’s “hear me out” list. Not only is he a male whose voice is pure sex; he’s also the sweetest, funniest, most capable sidekick a girl could ask for. 

What’s uniquely great about his romance is that instead of having both him and (female) Shepard declare their interest and have that be that, the game makes space for the considerable logistics that might be involved in interspecies intercourse. Some of the Mass Effect series’ funniest moments revolve around Shepard and Garrus trying to figure out how to make this crazy thing called love work.  – Ash Parrish

Tali

 Tali’Zorah vas Normandy is the romance option for folks who enjoy the “falling in love with your best friend’s little sister” trope. Even though Tali is not technically anyone’s little sister, that’s the vibe she brings to the Normandy along with a sharp wit and a very low alcohol tolerance. 

Like with the Garrus relationship for female Shepards, the Tali romance is pre-occupied with getting around the logistics of hooking up with a being for whom the tiniest bit of open-air exposure beyond her self-contained biosuit can have life-threatening implications. Like Liara, Tali transforms from a tech geek to a badass, but never quite loses her awkward and shy nature. Her romance in Mass Effect 3 is possibly the game’s best because Commander Shepard gets to be the ultimate boyfriend, gifting his girlfriend, whose people have been living as nomads across the galaxy for centuries, her very own planet to settle down on. — Ash Parrish

Liara

Liara is the Mass Effect love interest who writes Commander Shepard’s name in the stars. Over the course of three games, Liara romancers get the treat of seeing her grow from a naive, adorable nerd into a formidable badass at the head of her own slightly criminal empire. Being an Asari, a race of blue alien women who have the ability to reproduce with literally any species, Liara can romance either Shepard. 

It’s her romance that made BioWare the subject of salacious segments on Fox News declaring Mass Effect little better than pornography and questioning the “appropriateness” of depicting same-sex relationships in a video game “for kids”. She’s the one you can plan a family with as Shepard and Liara talk about a future filled with little blue children, offering hope that some part of Shepard’s story continues after the events of Mass Effect 3. – Ash Parrish

Solas 

Solas gets put in the BioWare romance hall of fame for being one of the best toxic boyfriends in all of video games. He is good specifically for how bad he hurts you, emotionally and physically. Solas shows up in Dragon Age Inquisition as an elven apostate mage—essentially a magical hobo. A female elven Inquisitor takes him in like a lost puppy and eventually a romance begins to bloom. 

He shares secrets pertaining to elven history, and talks of big plans to save their people from the oppression of humans. But during the moment when most other BioWare romances would be reaching their climax, he breaks up with you and won’t tell you why. It’s eventually revealed that he’s the one responsible for setting the events of Inquisition in motion, resulting in the world tearing itself apart and in the Inquisitor having a magic hand that’s slowly tearing her apart. That betrayal inspired an entire fandom of Dragon Age players who either wanted to redeem him when he returned as the big bad in Veilguard or, like I and many others wanted, to kill him. — Ash Parrish

Emmrich

Emmrich was not on my radar as a love interest in Dragon Age: The Veilguard. He’s old! And not like “elf who’s lived for thousands of years” old, he’s regular degular, graying-at-the-temples, wrinkles-in-the-face old. Once again, BioWare surprises and delights with a romance designed to represent the fact that love can be found at any time in life and sexual desire doesn’t disappear after a certain age. 

Emmrich’s romance doesn’t shy away from the reality that Rook is younger than he is and he’ll likely pass away (or not, depending on choices you can make) before they do. His romance asks players to consider that very real part of life in a way that just doesn’t get depicted in video games. AND!!! The fact that Emmrich is an old man doesn’t mean the sex is dry and boring. I was delighted—delighted I tell you!—when in the postcoital afterglow he was up, walking around and asking my Rook if she wanted some food while I was still half in bed. Old man broke MY back. Respect. — Ash Parrish

Alistair

Alistair is the number one BioWare cutie patootie. In Dragon Age: Origins he’s just a good wholesome farm boy conscripted into drinking demon blood that will eventually kill him. Alistair was my very first BioWare romance and I instantly fell for his golden-retriever charm. Despite his sad orphan upbringing and his doomed existence as a Grey Warden, Alistair never loses his goofy charm. He’s the jokester of the party without a serious bone in his body, a real knight in dull and battered armor that all these years later, I’ve never forgotten. — Ash Parrish

The Iron Bull

The Iron Bull is to Dragon Age romances what Garrus and Tali are to Mass Effect romances in that I can’t believe—but am delighted—that BioWare went for it and made the most “non-human” character in your squad actually romanceable. The Iron Bull is a qunari, a race of horned people whose culture is super religious. And while he isn’t the first qunari companion, he is the best, and he’s the first one you can romance in a Dragon Age game. 

Bull’s romance is special because unlike a number of others, you can keep it casual. And in the midst of this purely sexual relationship, the Inquisitor and Bull wind up having conversations about safe, sane, and consensual boundaries that very closely mimic the real-life conversations between people who practice kink. The Iron Bull’s romance is the first example I’ve seen in a AAA video game of  kink not being played for laughs or titillation but presented as a real, grounded lifestyle with rules and expectations. It’s a very different kind of romance that BioWare handled exceptionally well, aided by Freddie Prinze Jr’s voice work as the Iron Bull. — Ash Parrish

Morrigan

Morrigan from Dragon Age: Origins, with her dark makeup and impossible outfit literally held together with string, seems like an “I can fix her” romance when actually she’s a “She can make me worse” girl. Sis is a meme in the Dragon Age community mocking how anything the Grey Warden does that could even remotely be construed as heroic is met with the iconic pop-up, “Morrigan disapproves.” 

She is the mean girl to end all mean girls, and that doesn’t go away when you romance her. Her fierce dedication to her independence no matter her relationship status makes her one of those rare companions that makes you feel like you’ve fallen for a real person. A male Grey Warden can conceive a child with her, one you see grow throughout the Dragon Age quadrilogy, but except for a few brief moments throughout the series, the Grey Warden never really gets the chance to settle down with his family, making her romance part love story, part tragedy. — Ash Parrish

Kaidan Alenko

Kaidan is the first male love interest in the Mass Effect series, but in truth, his romantic relationship is best when viewed as a slow burn across the entire trilogy. That’s why a romantic relationship with him as Male Shepard, which was only made an option in Mass Effect 3 when BioWare decided to finally implement same-sex relationships for men, is one of the most profound love stories in the series. It suggests Kaidan and Shepard have been pining for each other for years, only to finally confess their feelings as the entire world is ending around them. Every kiss stolen between missions and military meetings is making up for years of “will-they-won’t-theys” and all that time they spent not even speaking to each other during Mass Effect 2. Now, they’re finally considering a future with one another that they don’t even know if they’ll get to have. The galaxy rests on their shoulders, but their sights are set on something smaller: the chance to spend just one more second of time together after all the time they foolishly wasted getting to this point. This all culminates in the two’s first and only on-screen “I love you” as Shepard makes a dash for the Citadel at the end of Mass Effect 3, hoping that whatever he finds there might guarantee that future, or, if it can’t, at least create one that Kaidan is alive to see. — Kenneth Shepard

Carth Onassi© BioWare

Carth Onasi

As a Mass Effect diehard, I have a soft spot for KOTOR’s Carth because he’s voiced by Kaidan actor Raphael Sbarge, but I will also give his romance, in which he reckons with the loss of one life and tries to imagine another, its flowers as one of BioWare’s early examples of a relationship tinged with grief and loss. He had a family once, and he lost them in an orbital strike by the Republic; his desire for revenge consumed him. Like many good revenge stories, KOTOR sees its would-be avenger reckon with what comes after the deed has been done, and if you’re pursuing a relationship with him, it might be you. BioWare games have you meet people at various stages of their lives, and there’s something poignant about knowing that you might not have been your partner’s first love, and that they’ve lived lives full of both triumph and tragedy. Carth can’t change the past, but you’re there to help him envision something new waiting for him on the other side of this struggle. — Kenneth Shepard

Fenris

The Fenris romance is like a recipe that calls for you to add a little bit of spice, but you accidentally pour the entire bottle of hot sauce into the concoction and then realize that’s exactly what it needed. Fenris is an angry person, having been forced into slavery under the Tevinter magisters and conditioned to view magic with skepticism at best, disdain at worst. So, what if he fell in love with a mage that he could not have been more ideologically opposed to? The Rivalry Romance, in which Dragon Age II protagonist Hawke repeatedly calls him out on his absolute hatred of magic users,hits with the kind of intensity your favorite AO3 fanfic can only dream of. It’s hot, heavy, heart-wrenching and, if you commit to doing the work to trust one another, has a happy ending.  Well, as happy as Dragon Age II can muster, I suppose. Trust in the face of a lifetime of conditioning is hard to come by, and allowing yourself to be vulnerable to something you’ve been taught doesn’t see you as a person feels downright impossible. Yet Fenris and Hawke find a way. — Kenneth Shepard

Dorian Pavus

Despite the fantastical framing, Dorian’s love story in Dragon Age: Inquisition is one that too many queer people are familiar with. He comes from an unsupportive family, having fled his home in Tevinter after his sexuality interfered with their planned legacy. Despite Dorian’s self-assured nature, entering a relationship with him can sometimes feel like stepping into a minefield filled with past traumas, only for them to blow up in your face. But what keeps the relationship afloat is his desire to unpack all the damage that’s been done with the Inquisitor by his side, and build something better in the space that’s left. Every queer person has some level of trauma to overcome, and even if he, like most of us, can’t deal with his trauma perfectly, his desire to do the work, and do it with someone, is why Dorian’s relationship works, even though he’s been given every reason to believe it can’t. — Kenneth Shepard