Steelers face QB decision after drafting Drew Allar, with Rodgers looming

The Pittsburgh Steelers may have added a potential quarterback of the future in Drew Allar, but their present situation remains far from settled—and it centers on one looming question involving Aaron Rodgers.

Pittsburgh selected Allar with the 76th pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, making him the fourth quarterback taken overall. The former Penn State standout brings an intriguing physical profile, boasting prototypical size, mobility, and arm strength that fits the mold of a modern NFL starter. On raw tools alone, Allar has the upside to eventually lead an offense at a high level.

However, his evaluation is anything but straightforward. While his tape flashes moments of high-end potential—tight-window throws, deep-ball velocity, and off-platform playmaking—there are notable inconsistencies that raise concerns. Allar’s footwork can be uneven, which impacts his accuracy, particularly on intermediate routes. His comfort level in the pocket also fluctuates, leading to stalled progressions and missed opportunities.

Those developmental areas matter even more given the current state of the Steelers’ quarterback room. This is not a franchise in full rebuild mode; Pittsburgh is built to compete now, with a roster capable of contending in the AFC. That urgency complicates the timeline for a player like Allar, who may need time before he is ready to take on a starting role.

That’s where Rodgers enters the equation. The veteran quarterback has been linked to Pittsburgh as a potential short-term solution, but no decision has been finalized. During the 2025 season, Rodgers threw for 3,782 yards with 26 touchdowns and 11 interceptions, completing 65.1% of his passes—numbers that reflect both his continued effectiveness and the natural signs of a veteran adjusting late in his career.

Rodgers or Allar will shape franchise future

For the Steelers, the choice is clear but difficult: pursue Rodgers and maximize their immediate championship window, or commit to developing Allar and accept the growing pains that may come with it.

Rodgers would offer stability, experience, and high-level play in the short term. But bringing him in could delay Allar’s development or limit his opportunities to gain meaningful reps. On the other hand, handing the reins to a rookie with clear flaws carries its own risks for a team with playoff aspirations.

Ultimately, the Steelers cannot afford to straddle both timelines for long. With Allar now in the building, a decision on Rodgers feels imminent—and it could define the direction of the franchise for years to come.