This year's Grammy nominations came out yesterday, and when my colleague Chris DeVille wrote his instant-reactions column, one of his takeaways was that "genre is over." Certain big stars have been nominated in categories that might not be their natural homes — Rosalía and Charli XCX in Alternative, Tame Impala in Dance, Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers in Rock. Certain artists aren't so happy about this.

The Wisconsin-born singer-songwriter Skylar Grey started off her career as a Linkin Park protege, but she's best known for collaborating with huge artists like Eminem and Dr. Dre. (She co-wrote Eminem's hit Rihanna collab "Love The Way You Lie.") Her most recent solo album Wasted Potential came out earlier this year. Grey has been nominated for her work with other artists a few times in the past, but Wasted Potential didn't get any Grammys attention. The same way that John Summit is mad about how the Grammys define "dance," Grey has some issues with the awards show's version of "rock."

In a social-media video posted after the Grammy nominations came out yesterday, Grey told Alexa, "Play me a song nominated for a Grammy in the rock category." She then shook her head frustratedly when she heard the first few notes of Olivia Rodrigo's Robert Smith duet "What's Wrong With Me" and Phoebe Bridgers' single "Lost Boys," both of which are up for Best Rock Performance. (The other nominees in the category are Angine De Poitrine's "Sarniezz," Geese's Trinidad," and the Rolling Stones' "In The Stars.") Then Grey told Alexa, "Play me the #1 rock song right now" and nodded in satisfaction when she heard "R.I.P.," the recent Motionless In White single that features her.

Grey captioned the video with a note for the Grammys to "do better." During the clip, these words appear onscreen: "Hey Alexa, did the Grammys forget what rock music is?"

First off, that's not how Alexa works. Even if it were, why would someone's personal Amazon assistant be the authority on what rock music is? Grammy voters seem to have difficulty assessing genre, but why would that be any better? And in asking for "the #1 rock song," Grey asked for the rock song currently being played the most on rock radio stations, and that's probably even worse. None of these entities should get to decide these things. Come on.

"R.I.P.," the Motionless In White song that features Skylar Grey, is currently at #1 on Billboard's Mainstream Rock Airplay chart. But Olivia Rodrigo is all over the current Billboard rock charts, too. So is Noah Kahan. So what are we doing here?