1 hour ago
3
Major League Baseball’s social media pages are usually where fans go for moonshot homers, milestone chases and highlight-reel catches.
Last week, the league used them for something a little less celebratory: making its case in the early days of a brewing labor fight with the players union.
As collective bargaining talks heat up ahead of the current CBA’s expiration on Dec. 1, MLB has begun pushing messages about its salary-cap and salary-floor proposal through its official fan-facing accounts — the same feeds typically used to showcase the sport’s best moments and star players.
On Facebook, X and Instagram, MLB framed the league’s massive payroll disparity as the biggest issue baseball fans want fixed, arguing in a lengthy post that too many fans begin seasons “without hope of their team competing for a World Series title.”
The messaging pointed to the league’s proposed cap-and-floor system as a solution that would “level the playing field,” with the Dodgers and Mets approaching $400 million payrolls while clubs such as the Guardians and Marlins sit below $100 million.
The argument was familiar and expected, but the delivery was different. The league was not merely issuing a press release or leaking its position through reporters. It was putting its labor case directly in front of fans on its social platforms.
Public jockeying has gone both ways. The MLBPA also has taken its case directly to fans in recent months, releasing exhaustive details of its own CBA proposal and arguing that the league’s cap plan would suppress player salaries. But MLB’s use of its main league accounts stands out because those platforms are designed less for labor messaging than for marketing the game itself.
MLB spokesperson Glen Caplin told The Post the league has “a responsibility to communicate directly with fans through every available channel.”
“A salary cap and salary floor, as used by every other major U.S. professional sports league, would create a more level playing field and give every club a fair chance to compete,” Caplin said.
The MLBPA pushed back strongly on the league’s messaging.
“With the All-Star Game approaching, and what should be a celebration of our game, MLB seems to be spending most of its efforts on a political ad-style campaign trying to mislead fans into thinking that the game they love is broken to justify a system that would put more money in the owners’ pockets,” interim MLBPA executive director Bruce Meyer said in a statement to The Post.
Labor experts said MLB’s social media push marks a meaningful shift in the league’s approach to labor talks.
“This approach is unusual but probably inevitable, given how people consume information,” said Michael LeRoy, a labor and employment relations professor at the University of Illinois. “Commissioner [Rob] Manfred is likely forging new ground here.”
LeRoy said the tactic is “night-and-day different” from a commissioner’s letter or formal bargaining statement, adding that unions are likely to view such messaging as “a ploy” and an indication of “bargaining through tweets and social media posts.”
Forbes contributor Maury Brown, who covers the business of baseball, also noted the distinction between the league using its main social media channels and more traditional avenues.
“If you thought MLB might pull back some in order to prevent a protracted lockout, here they are using the league’s social media channel — not their Communications account — to push the cap system and concessions they accepted to make it happen,” Brown wrote on X. “This has never happened with any prior labor negotiations in the social media age.”
MLB has appealed directly to fans during labor fights before, including when Manfred issued a letter after CBA talks dragged into March in 2022. But the use of everyday league social feeds during active bargaining represents a different, more immediate kind of public pressure campaign, experts said.
Eugene Freedman, a union-side labor lawyer, said MLB’s approach also stands out because of the league’s complicated history of publicly framing labor disputes involving its own players.
“I think MLB is different than many of the other sports in how it negatively portrays its players — its product — both during and outside CBA negotiations,” Freedman told The Post. “The NBA especially has for decades promoted its most prominent players as the game itself.”
That makes MLB’s use of its fan-facing accounts especially notable, experts said, because those platforms are built around the players whose compensation and working conditions are at the center of the dispute.
For MLB, that means a labor message about payroll disparity can appear in the same space as a walk-off home run or a tribute to one of the sport’s biggest stars.
As MLB and the players’ union move toward another high-stakes CBA fight, the league’s social media strategy offers an early glimpse at how public — and how direct — this round could become.
English (US)