How Diddy, The Menendez Brothers, Luigi Mangione Are Connected

3 hours ago 1

Sean "Diddy" Combs' Daughters Walk Out of Courtroom During Testimony

Some connections in the legal world go beyond professional.

As Sean “Diddy” Combs, Luigi Mangione and the Menendez Brothers are amid their respective high-profile legal battles, they have a lot in common when it comes to those representing them on the case. After all, it appears two families of lawyers are taking on the weight of these cases.

For Combs’ sex trafficking trial that began May 12—in which he pleaded not guilty to charges of sex trafficking, prostitution, racketeering conspiracy, sex trafficking by force, fraud, or coercion, as well as transportation to engage in prostitution—Marc Agnifilo has taken on the role of lead counsel. By his side is Teny Geragos, a partner at Agnifilio’s firm. 

With Marc and Teny busy in a New York City courthouse as Cassie Ventura and other witnesses for the prosecution have since taken the stand, their loved ones are working on their own legal cases. 

While Marc’s wife Karen Friedman Agnifilo is busy preparing for her client Luigi Mangione’s upcoming trial for the murder of United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson last December, Teny’s father Mark Geragos is celebrating a major win with his case. 

Los Angeles County Judge Michael Jesic officially ruled that Lyle Menendez and Erik Menendez’s life sentences for the 1989 murders of their parents José Menendez and Mary Louise "Kitty" Menendez would be reduced to 50 years to life with the possibility of parole, according to NBC News. 

“Now we see the pot at the end of the rainbow, so to speak, or their freedom,” Mark, whose clients have already spent more than 30 years in prison, told reporters outside the L.A. courthouse. “One of the things I think is important is to recognize, like the legislators have done, we have evolved. This is not the ‘90s anymore. We have a more robust understanding of a lot of things.”

Shareif Ziyadat/Getty Images for Sean "Diddy" Combs

Meanwhile, Karen—who met now-husband Marc in 1992—has been busy preparing to return to court in December. Luigi, 26, pleaded not guilty in April to federal charges—two counts of stalking, one count of murder through a firearm, as well as one count of firearms offense for an allegation that he used a silencer—in connection with the shooting. (He has also pleaded not guilty to New York state charges in December. He is facing five charges in Pennsylvania, where he has not entered a plea yet.)

She previously shared insight into his defense’s potential strategy, telling CNN in December before she took the case, “There might be a not guilty by reason of insanity defense that they’re going to be thinking about because the evidence is going to be so overwhelming that he did what he did.”

VINCE BUCCI/AFP via Getty Images

“As a former prosecutor in that office, I would be concerned that you have someone who is a valedictorian of his class, he was brilliant his whole life, he comes from this great family,” she continued. “Something changed, significantly, something changed.”

Along with a notable name, Karen said she’s learned a lot from Marc—who previously represented NXVIM leader Keith Raniere in his 2018 sex-trafficking case for which he was sentenced to 120 years in prison.

“There’s no crime necessarily that I wouldn’t take or even set of factors that I wouldn’t take,” she said on the Shut Up Mommy’s Talking podcast in 2022. “I do believe that everyone’s entitled to a defense and to good representation, and I’ve always believed that.”

For a deeper look at Marc’s work on Diddy’s legal team, keep reading.

Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/FilmMagic

Sean "Diddy" Combs Allegedly Told Cassie Ventura That She "Couldn't" Leave Him During Hotel Attack

Cassie Ventura, taking the stand for the second day as a witness, recounted the 2016 hotel attack that was caught on surveillance footage and shared by CNN in May 2024. 

She testified that Sean “Diddy” Combs threw a vase at her after attempting to leave the Intercontinental Hotel before physically assaulting her.

“I just remember it coming towards me,” Ventura said of the vase while on the stand May 14. “It hit the wall. I didn’t get hit. He was yelling at me. He threw it at me, I don't remember exactly his words. I'm sure he was calling me something other than my name.”

However, she said that Combs told her “that I wasn’t going to leave him, that I couldn’t.”

Shortly after the hotel attack, Ventura said she had to attend the premiere of her film The Perfect Match with bruises on her face and body alongside Combs. Along with having to apply heavy makeup to cover up her black eye and fat lip, she added, “I had several bruises on my legs, so I changed my outfit.”

Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

Cassie Ventura Says Sean "Diddy" Combs Attacked Her in Hotel Hallway Because She Left a "Freak Off"

Cassie Ventura testified May 13 that Sean “Diddy” Combs attacked her in the hallway of a Los Angeles hotel in March 2016 because he was mad she walked out of a “freak off.” (Hotel surveillance footage of the incident was published by CNN in 2024. The defense unsuccessfully tried to have the video excluded from evidence.)

“I chose to leave,” Ventura told the court. “I got out and Sean followed me into the hallway, and grabbed me, shoved me to the ground, kicked me and dragged me back to the room and took my stuff.”

She hadn’t wanted to participate, but she had a movie premiere a couple of days later and wanted to placate Combs, she said. “If I pleased him with a freak off,” Ventura said, “then my premiere would run smoothly.”

He gave her a black eye, she continued, and “at this point all I could think about was getting out of there safely. I had my premiere and I didn’t want to mess it up.” Once he pushed her to the ground in the hallway, Ventura said, she stayed down because “she didn’t want him to do any more damage than he had already done.”

Matthew Eisman/Getty Images

Cassie Ventura Says She Took Drugs to Make It Through “Freak Offs”

Ventura testified that she drank alcohol and took ecstasy when she first had sex with an escort in front of Combs. And to make it through “freak offs,” she said, she would take "marijuana, ketamine, mushrooms, whatever was the drug of choice at that point.”

“I couldn’t imagine myself doing any of that without having some sort of buffer,” she said.

Sometimes she would “actually vomit” during a "freak off," Ventura continued, and Combs “would encourage me to get up and continue on with it.”

She wanted Combs to know that the "freak offs" made her feel “horrible” and “worthless,” Ventura said, but he was “pretty dismissive” of her concerns.

Broadimage Entertainment/Shutterstock

Cassie Ventura Describes Mess of Oil, Urine and Blood After "Freak Offs"

After a “freak off,” there would be baby oil all over the hotel room, Ventura testified, and if Combs had instructed someone to urinate on her, there might be urine on the sheets. And, if she was menstruating at the time, Ventura said, there could be blood on the sheets and furniture as well.

Being urinated on made her feel “humiliated,” Ventura said. “It was disgusting, it was too much. I choked, I didn’t want to be doing that, I was in a position I couldn’t easily get out of.”

“It was a turn-on for him, so it happened,” Ventura said. Asked by prosecutor Emily A. Johnson why she didn’t refuse Combs' directions in these cases, she replied, “I thought that it was obvious that I didn’t want to do it.”

Elizabeth Williams via AP

Sean “Diddy” Combs Wanted Baby Oil “Glistening” During “Freak Offs,” Says Cassie Ventura

Ventura testified May 13 that Combs directed her and other “freak off” participants to cover themselves in baby oil.

“Sean wanted it heated and he wanted it to be glistening,” she said in court, “so we applied every five minutes.”

During one such “freak off” at the Montage Beverly Hills, Ventura said, Combs asked her to get into an inflatable “pool filled with baby oil,” while she was wearing clothes.

She didn’t want to, but if it was something Combs “wanted to happen, that’s what was going to happen,” she continued. “We used 10 bottles of baby oil, regular size.”

Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images/Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/FilmMagic

Cassie Ventura Said Hiring For “Freak Offs” Became “a Job” For Her

Ventura told prosecutors May 13 that during the first year of her decade-long relationship with Combs, he “proposed” the introduction of voyeurism into their sexual relationship. It first began with her “hiring an escort and setting up” so that she could “perform” for Combs, who would watch her with another person.

Eventually, she said, orchestrating sex performances Combs called "freak offs," which could last anywhere from 36 hours to four days, “became a job” for her.

“I had the contacts to set it up in the hotel room and all of that,” she recalled, “at the beginning Sean set it up.”

Ventura said that her “stomach churned” when he first proposed the experience.

“I didn’t have a concept of how that would be a turn on, but I accepted the responsibility,” she said. “I was confused, nervous, but also loved him very much and wanted to make him happy. It wasn't something that I wanted to be doing, especially as regularly as it became, but again, i was in love and wanted to make him happy.”

She admitted, “At some point, I felt I didn't have much of a choice.”

Neilson Barnard/Getty Images

Cassie Ventura Alleges “Violent Arguments” With Sean “Diddy” Combs Led to “Physical Abuse and Dragging”

Ventura, who dated Combs on and off from 2007 to 2018, said that he was “frequently” violent towards her during their relationship.

"Yes, they were violent arguments, usually resulted in physical abuse and dragging, different things," she testified to jurors. "He would mash my head, knock me over, drag me, kick me."

She said that her injuries were often visible, adding, “I would get knots on my forehead, black eyes, red eyes, bruises all over my body.”

Allen Berezovsky / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES; Paras Griffin / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES

Defense Wanted Pregnant Cassie Ventura Seated Before Jury to Avoid "Sympathy"

With Ventura ready to take the stand after male escort Daniel Phillip May 13, Combs’ defense requested that she be seated in the witness box before the jury enters, since she is eight months pregnant.

“Because I think there is a prejudicial quality,” defense attorney Marc Agnifilo told the judge. "Pregnancy is beautiful and wonderful. It is also a source of potential sympathy."

Ventura was ultimately brought in after the jury was seated, indicating that his defense team lost the motion.

Johnny Nunez/WireImage

Male Escort Says He Could Hear Sean "Diddy" Combs Assaulting Cassie

When Ventura didn’t join Combs right when he called for her on one occasion, Phillip testified May 12 that Combs threw a liquor bottle in her direction, then grabbed her by her hair and dragged her into the bedroom. “She was screaming,” Phillip said, and, from the next room, ”what I heard sounded like him slapping her.” Phillip said he heard Combs say, “’I tell you to come here, you come here now, not later.’”

Phillip said he was “terrified” and did not intervene.

He further testified that he overheard what sounded like Combs assaulting Ventura on a separate occasion at the Essex House hotel in New York. “I heard her yelling, 'I’m sorry, I’m sorry,' someone was being slapped around and slammed around the room," Phillip said. "And I looked around the corner and I saw Mr. Combs walk out of the hotel altogether without clothes, he might have had a towel on.”

Ventura came out of the room and jumped into Phillip’s lap, he testified. “She basically tried to convince me that 'it's OK' and 'I’ll be OK,’” Phillip continued. “And I said, 'It is not OK and you need to get help.'”

“I tried to explain to her that she was in real danger if she stayed with him,” Phillip said.

Asked by prosecutor Maureen Comey why he didn’t call the police, Phillip testified that he thought of Combs as “someone with unlimited power, and chances are, even if I did go to the police, that I might still end up losing my life.”

Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images

Escort Says Cassie Ventura Paid for Sex While Sean "Diddy" Combs Watched and Masturbated

Daniel Phillip, who said he was running a male stripper revue during the time in question, testified that he was paid “a few thousand dollars” to have sex with Ventura while Combs watched at Manhattan’s Gramercy Hotel in 2012. Phillip said that Combs wore a robe, a baseball cap and a bandanna covering his face, but he recognized him by his voice.

Ventura paid him and said she “would tip me when I leave," Phillip told the court. "We ended up having sex, rubbed baby oil on each other for a couple minutes. [Combs] was sitting in a corner masturbating.”

Afterward, the witness continued, Ventura gave him “a couple of thousand more.”

Phillip said that he was contacted multiple times over the next year to have similar encounters with Ventura and Combs at other hotels and at their respective homes in New York. He said that Combs recorded him and Ventura having sex once or twice, and that sometimes Combs would intervene and have sex with Ventura while Phillip was there.

In her 2023 lawsuit accusing her ex of sexual assault and physical abuse, Ventura alleged Combs forced her to have sex with male prostitutes.

AaronP/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images

Cassie Ventura Had “Purple Eye” After Being Attacked by Sean "Diddy" Combs, According to Witness

Ventura “was scared," Florez said on the stand. "She was in the corner, hood on, covered up. I couldn't see her face, she was pretty much in the corner. On the floor was a destroyed flower vase."

When Ventura left the hotel she had a “purple eye,” Florez said. Once she was gone, Florez said, he and the desk manager went upstairs to remind Combs of “hotel rules.” Combs thought the manager was recording him on his phone and grabbed it, Florez continued, and when Combs tried to grab his phone, Florez said he pinned Combs against a wall. "We said we are not recording you,” Florez testified, “and de-escalated the situation.”

Prosecutors showed the surveillance footage of the attack—in which Combs appears to be hitting, kicking and dragging Ventura—that was slowed down from what was published by CNN in May 2024. (The defense had previously alleged that the clip was sped up, making the altercation look more violent than it was.) The jury was also shown video that Florez recorded on his cell phone when he responded to a call of a woman in distress on the sixth floor.

Florez testified that he did not call police at the time because Ventura wouldn’t answer questions about what happened and told him she just wanted to leave.

John Lamparski/Getty Images

Former Hotel Security Guard Says Sean "Diddy" Combs Offered Him Cash to Stay Quiet About Cassie Attack

Los Angeles Police Officer Israel Florez was a security guard at the InterContinental Hotel when Combs attacked Ventura on March 5, 2016. (In her opening statement, Geragos called surveillance footage of the attack, which was first published by CNN in May 2024, “overwhelming evidence of domestic violence,” but over infidelity discovered on a cell phone and “not over sex trafficking.”)

Florez testified May 12 that he saw evidence of an altercation on the morning in question, and Combs offered him “a stack of money” to look the other way.

Under cross-examination, Florez said he “100 percent” interpreted the gesture to be Combs trying to bribe him.

Ricky Vigil/GC Images

Defense Says Sean "Diddy" Combs Is "Complicated," the Case Is Not

In her opening statement, defense attorney Teny Geragos said prosecutors were trying to turn consensual sex into sex trafficking, but “it will not work.”

“Sean Combs is a complicated man,” she said, “but this is not a complicated case.”

“This case is about Sean Combs’ private, personal sex life,” Geragos continued, “which has nothing to do with his lawful businesses.”

Her client was violent, took drugs and had anger issues, she told the court, and there will be times during this trial when “you think he is a jerk, he is mean. But he is not charged with being mean. He is not charged with being a jerk.”

Geragos said, “The evidence is going to show you a very flawed individual, but it will not show you a racketeer, a sex trafficker or somebody transporting for prostitution.”

Laura Cavanaugh / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES

Prosecution Accuses Sean "Diddy" Combs of Being a Kingpin During His Trial

Prosecutor Emily Johnson accused Combs of using a sprawling network of employees to carry out illegal acts, like dayslong “freak offs,” which were detailed in the federal indictment, according to NBC News reporters in the courtroom.

“He sometimes called himself the king and expected to be treated like one to cater to all his desires,” she told the jury. “He used his companies to manipulate women, forcing them with male escorts to have sex while he watched. He and his inner circle made sure he got everything he wanted."

Mark Sagliocco / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES

Opening Statements From the Prosecution at Sean "Diddy" Combs’ Sex Trafficking Trial Begins

 Johnson began her argument before the jury by describing Combs as a “larger than life" person who ran a criminal enterprise.

Highlighting an example of his alleged criminality, Johnson told the jury that the Bad Boys Record founder was “on the hunt" for Ventura one night after he learned that she had begun a romantic relationship with someone else. Johnson accused Combs of beating “her brutally, kicking her in the back and flinging her around like a rag doll” after he found her.

“He threatened her and said if she defies her again he will release video of her having sex with male escorts," she continued. "Souvenirs of the most humiliating nights of her life."

The prosecutor alleged that Combs’ inner circle covered up “crime after crime.”

Paras Griffin / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES

When Will Sean "Diddy" Combs’ Sex Trafficking Trial End?

Presiding Judge Arun Subramanian told jurors that he believes the trial will possibly conclude by July 4. He said that he hopes the trial will be done by then, although it “could go longer, but I don't expect that it will."

TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images

Sean "Diddy" Combs’ Kids Show Their Support At His Trial

As the rap mogul arrived for the first day of his sex trafficking trial May 12, his mom Janice Combs was present along with six of his eldest kids.

His and late ex Kim Porter’s kids Quincy Brown, Christian “King” Combs, Jessie Combs and D’Lila Combs, his and ex Misa Hylton's son Justin Combs, as well as his and ex Sarah Chapman's daughter Chance Combs had the chance to greet their dad with a hug before he sat down with his attorneys.

Erika Goldring / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES

Who is on the 12-Person Jury For Sean "Diddy" Combs’ Trial?

The prosecution and Combs’ defense team agreed to a jury of eight men and four women, as well as four men and two women as alternates for the trial.

Combs’ attorney Marc Agnifilo argued that the prosecution was intentionally removing potential Black jurors, telling the judge that it “leads to a pattern and they need to give reason for strikes.”

However, prosecutor Maurene Ryan Comey denied the accusations, responding, “We have conducted ourselves without any bias. The jury is diverse with a number of nonwhite (panelists).”

The 12 jurors live in New York City or Westchester include a 69-year-old male actor and massage; a 31-year-old male investment analyst; a 51-year-old male scientist; a 30-year-old female deli clerk; a 42-year-old female nursing home aide; a 41-year-old male communications clerk at a correctional facility; a 68-year-old male retired banker; a 68-year-old retired telecommunications company; a 43-year-old female physician assistant; a 39-year-old male social worker; a 67-year-old male logistics analystand a 74-year-old female treatment coordinator.

For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App

Read Entire Article