Giants have nothing to lose, and Tony Vitello wants to see them play like it

KANSAS CITY — For too much of this season, in manager Tony Vitello’s eyes, the Giants have been playing as if they have “everything to lose.” He’d like to see more of the opposite.

“And that’s understandable,” Vitello said. “It’s one of the most, if not the most, proud organizations in the MLB. We’ve got a lot of talent on the roster. But I think somewhere along the line, we were a little late to the party on flipping that switch a little bit.”

Giants manager Tony Vitello (left) wants his players to compete like they have nothing to lose. AP Photo/Charlie Riedel

At this point, 18 games below .500 (42-60) and 22 ½ back of the Dodgers, you could say Vitello’s squad has nothing left to lose. And never has that mindset been more evident than the past two times a Giants player has taken off from first base attempting to swipe second.

Bryce Eldridge and Daniel Susac made it safely, just as the Giants’ previous 10 base stealers had before them. San Francisco is 12-for-12 on steals in 16 games in July, already matching its most in one month with still more than a week of games left to play.

It might be too late for it to matter, but it’s never too late to improve an area that has been a problem, especially if it can carry over into next season. Even with their recent uptick, the Giants still only have six more stolen bases (39) than the league’s least successful running team, the Tigers (33). Dating back to 2022, no team has been less aggressive on the basepaths. 

“We’ve tried to be more aggressive,” Vitello said. With calls from the dugout, “We’ve tried to be a little bit more ambitious about initiating just a straight steal.”

But in the case of Eldridge and Susac, neither of whom would call themselves particularly fleet-footed, the steals weren’t a product of a call from the coaching staff. Both players possess sprint speeds in the bottom 40% of big leaguers, among the four-slowest Giants.

But each of them took off on his own.

Eldridge didn’t even need to get his uniform dirty to notch his first career stolen base.

“He was basically just giving it to me,” Eldridge said. “They didn’t think I was going to run, and I don’t blame them. … Guys don’t really pay attention to me on the bases, so that’s something I can take advantage of. I’ve really got nothing to lose in that situation.”

Music to Vitello’s ears.

“With Bryce,” the manager joked, “it’s a hold-your-breath moment, to be honest with you.”

Susac wasn’t as fortunate. He scraped his hand on a slide into second that showed his inexperience on the basepaths — and made him the butt of some jokes.

Vitello wants to see his players take more chances, especially during a lost season with no realistic chance of making the postseason. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

But consider the thought process.

“I just saw the first pitch was a little slow, and with the clock being at like five (seconds), I was like, I don’t think he’s gonna pick, so I’m just gonna take off and take my chance,” Susac said. “Obviously it ended up working out. But I’m definitely not a burner by any means, so I pick and choose my spots.”

Again, that’s the kind of smart-but-carefree ball Vitello would like to see more of.

“It goes to show you he’s fully capable of doing those things,” Vitello said. “We were kind of joking about the slide out there when we made a pitching change. … It wasn’t ideal.”

Both steals came when the Giants were trailing late in the game and with two outs in the inning, and neither resulted in anything more. But they shared something else in common: Players trying to make something happen on their own. Susac wanted to put himself in scoring position for Luis Arraez; Rafael Devers was at the plate when Eldridge took off.

Jesus Rodriguez later dropped down a successful sacrifice bunt.

Perhaps it’s no coincidence that was the theme of a recent hitters’ meeting.

“A couple of the team leaders spoke up [Tuesday] in the offensive meeting about don’t be afraid to wait for the coaches to initiate anything,” Vitello said. “Whether you see an opportunity for a bunt, or an opportunity to run, anything like that, don’t be afraid to try and create.”

There’s nothing the Giants can realistically do about their dashed postseason dreams. But they can control the mindset they take to the ballpark each day.

“You’re not playing like you have nothing to lose because you don’t care,” Vitello said. “But I think a little bit more of a loose and a little bit more of a carefree approach could benefit us.”