Gary Cohen, Keith Hernandez had enough of brutal umpiring in Mets-Diamondbacks series: ‘El stinko’

9 hours ago 1

Gary Cohen and Keith Hernandez didn’t hide their feelings about the umpiring crew in charge of this week’s Mets-Diamondbacks series.

And Thursday’s matinee got to a point where both really made sure to let their SNY audience know how they felt.

Things came to a head in the top of the ninth in Arizona’s 4-2 win at Citi Field when the Diamondbacks loaded the bases with two outs and slugger Eugenio Suarez up at the plate.

Gary Cohen and Keith Hernandez are apoplectic over home plate umpire John Bacon and CB Bucknor's crew.

"I mean, come on… I mean, what's going on, Keith?" – Cohen.

"These two series in a row just el stinko." – Hernandez. pic.twitter.com/zW8LXjOjJp

— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) May 1, 2025

Reliever Ty Adcock’s slider in a 1-2 count didn’t break back over the plate, but the ball did clearly hit the bat of Suarez and landed in catcher Luis Torrens’ glove, which would’ve been a foul tip strike three.

Both Torrens and manager Carlos Mendoza pleaded with home plate umpire John Bacon, who did not seem to agree and called the pitch a ball.

Cohen then tore into Bacon’s ability to call the game behind the dish.

The Mets argued that the ball had hit Suarez’s bat.

“John Bacon does not seem to know the difference between a ball hitting a bat and a bat hitting a glove. That was clear a foul tip for strike three. … I mean, what’s going on, Keith?”

After Suarez popped out to end the inning, Hernandez then summarized his feelings on the umpiring crews from the past two series.

“Two series in a row just el stinko,” the ex-Mets first baseman said.

John Bacon was in Gary Cohen’s crosshairs.

Notably, during the last series in Washington, Jesse Winker hit into a triple play in the opener after his line drive to first base was incorrectly called a catch, as multiple replays on the TV broadcast showed the ball hit the ground, which would’ve kept the ball in play and likely eliminated a triple play.

Winker was at the center of another controversial call during Wednesday’s game in which he appeared to foul a ball off his foot with the bases loaded in the ninth inning.

It was instead ruled a fair ball and ended up as an RBI groundout.

Two batters later, the Mets lost, 4-3.

Gary Cohen and Keith Hernandez (center, right) were both fuming about the umpiring. SNY

All three plays were not reviewable.

The Mets next head to St. Louis for a series with the Cardinals after losing two out of three against Arizona.

Read Entire Article