Elmo’s NBA Finals neutrality draws ire of Knicks fans: ‘Not rocking with you’

Elmo causing NBA Finals drama probably wasn’t on your bingo card.

The famed “Sesame Street” puppet is getting pushback from fervent New York basketball fans after wishing both the Knicks and Spurs well before Wednesday night’s NBA Finals Game 1.

“Elmo hopes both teams have fun,” the Muppet wrote on X before the start of the Finals.

Sesame Street Muppet ‘Elmo’ attends the Sesame Workshop’s 13th Annual Benefit Gala at Cipriani 42nd Street on May 27, 2015 in New York City. WireImage

The post has since drawn over 12 million views and over a thousand comments, mainly from irate Knicks fans stunned Elmo wasn’t fully endorsing his hometown team before its first NBA Finals game since 1999.

Sesame Street is canonically a New York City street — the show was originally filmed in Manhattan before moving to Queens in 1993.

“Elmo this is the first time I’m not rocking with you. You gotta root for your city man!” X user @UTxJGTheDon replied in the comments.

“Hey man, you from Sesame Street, in the middle of New York City. You better be rooting for the Knicks!” another New York sports fan, @RonDeLaPena, wrote on X.

Several of the comments used colorful language not appropriate for the PBS show, and others used anatomical words to describe their feelings about the post.

Even with Elmo getting serious backlash, the Knicks rallied back from down 14 points in the third quarter to steal Game 1 of the Finals 105-95.

Knicks fans celebrate outside Madison Square Garden in Manhattan on Wednesday, June 3, 2026, during the first NBA finals game between the Knicks and the Spurs. (Robert Mecea for New York Post) Robert Mecea for New York Post

In the Knicks’ first Finals win in 27 years, Jalen Brunson stole the show with a game-high 30 points on 12-of-31 shooting.

Brunson struggled in the first half, but hit a clutch 3 to put the Knicks up 97-95 with under two minutes remaining, and they wouldn’t relinquish that lead.

Karl-Anthony Towns also starred in his first NBA Finals game with 18 points and 12 rebounds, while Josh Hart grabbed 15 boards and added four steals despite only having three points.

Spurs star Victor Wembanyama couldn’t fit his footing, shooting just 6-of-21 from the field.

San Antonio aims to even the series Friday night at 8:30 p.m. ET.