ECB Risks Repeating 2011 Mistake With Rate Hike, Economists Warn

Article content

The most recent experience, in 2021-2022, showed the perils of waiting, however. Russia’s attack on Ukraine jolted energy markets and sent inflation to a record 10.6%. Despite an unprecedented campaign of monetary tightening, many said the ECB acted too late.

Article content

For former ECB Chief Economist Peter Praet, “at some point you have to show that you’re willing to act.”

Article content

While Finland’s Olli Rehn has described this week’s likely action as an “insurance hike,” Praet said it’s more like “a warning shot to show you mean it.” He stressed, however, the “importance” of not signaling “that this is the first in a series of hikes.”

Article content

There are those who see a rate increase as justified, even if shifting data prompt a rethink down the line. Economic expansion is waning, particularly in France. Business activity is shrinking at the quickest pace since 2024.

Article content

The euro-zone economy shrank at the start of the year after an unprecedented contraction in Ireland forced a revision to data that originally showed feeble growth. Excluding Irish figures, it grew 0.2%-0.3%, according to Bantleon calculation.

Article content

Article content

Policymakers will “give themselves scope to say if the situation changes materially, if the economy really starts to deteriorate in the way some of these surveys are showing, we will cut,” Katharine Neiss, chief European economist at PGIM, told Bloomberg TV.

Article content

“They will do it in a way that gives them the space to do that without the reversal affecting their credibility,” she said, predicting a “dovish tone.”

Article content

Like investors, economists see two quarter-point rate rises this year, possibly what President Christine Lagarde meant by a “measured adjustment” to an inflation overshoot that’s big but should be temporary. They see at least one cut in mid-2027, however.

Article content

Jens Eisenschmidt, chief European economist at Morgan Stanley who’s worked at the ECB in the past, predicts two hikes in the months ahead, with both to be undone next year. That outcome shouldn’t be viewed as a policy error, though, he said.

Article content

A June move to address above-target inflation and rising price expectations “would likely be a carefully-weighed decision under uncertainty,” Eisenschmidt said. “Likewise, a decision to cut rates a year after would likely be motivated by an assessment that the insurance provided by a tighter policy stance was no longer needed.”

Article content

Such justifications don’t fly for some. Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg, reckons ECB tightening will burden households and firms unnecessarily, with inflation pressures likely to dissipate regardless due to economic weakness.

Article content

There’s “no need for an ECB hike amid consumer misery,” he said. Given headwinds to demand, “the inevitable temporary surge in prices seems unlikely to turn into a protracted inflation problem to be addressed by rate hikes.”

Article content