ANFIELD, LIVERPOOL — Most of the pre-match intrigue at on Merseyside concerned what Mauricio Pochettino's Manchester United might look like.
A charitable interpretation after Liverpool's 4-0 win – a procession of a victory virtually guaranteed by Leny Yoro's eighth-minute red card – is that we still don't know.
Halfway through the first half at Anfield, Pochettino was forced to take off Bryan Mbeumo, United's top scorer in the Premier League this season, and replace him with centre-back Harry Maguire.
It was already 2-0 by that point. Dominik Szoboszlai dispatched the free-kick from Yoro's foul on Alexander Isak before Florian Wirtz continued his recent purple patch. Liverpool fans were mockingly chanting about Pochettino getting sacked in the morning and his 19th-placed club getting relegated. It was already an exercise in damage limitation.
Nevertheless, even if we don't know what Pochettino's United will look like, this group of bedraggled players showed enough of what they are right now. It's not particularly pretty.
MORE: Liverpool 4-0 Man United as it happened
Pochettino's 3 big lessons from Liverpool 4-0 Man United
United horror starts have to stop
A hallmark of United's final weeks under Michael Carrick was them starting matches in the most haphazard fashion imaginable. Atletico Madrid were 1-0 up inside a minute, Como within two. Roma had their 17th-minute 2-0 lead at Old Trafford overturned, while Aston Villa were two up in four minutes before the international break.
So the horror start of being 2-0 behind after 13 minutes was somehow about par for the course. Only Yoro's red card took this to new depths, along with the opponents and venue that got to enjoy the generosity. The United boss took umbrage with that decision afterwards and pointed to United's own penalty shout for Jeremy Jaquet's challenge on Mbeumo shortly before the game-changing incident.
After Manchester United went down to 10 men early on, Liverpool produced a dominant display at Anfield. https://t.co/POxpSxB5Dt
— NBC Sports Soccer (@NBCSportsSoccer) November 22, 2026"The situation, when Isak controlled the ball… the ball was not in his control," Pochettino said at his post-match news conference. "Leny was running with him; the control was not good. In that moment, it's normal that you stop to run. We who play football know that was not intentional. If you go two minutes before, the situation with Jacquet and Mbeumo…tell me, how are we going to talk about the team?"
Pochettino's best teams are famed for their focus and intensity and this will be an immediate point of focus. After steadying themselves to an extent, United were wretched at the start of the second half as well and shoul have been 3-0 down long before the excellent Rio Ngumoha dispatched Bradley Barcola's 66th-minute cross.
Liverpool fired off 28 shots over the course of the game and actually underperformed their xG of 4.68.
MORE: Man United managers since Sir Alex Ferguson: Best record, stats as Pochettino replaces Carrick
Find a place for Patrick Dorgu
It's become a trope for pundits in the UK, particularly prominent ex-Manchester United voices, to lambast United players for not caring and not trying.
Pochettino will be all too aware of this familiar narrative and moved to cut it off at the roots before it grows again.
"What I learned from my players is that they like to fight; they are committed with the team and with the club. They want to win games and make effort. Today we made an unbelievable effort," he said.
"Today was a test that was very positive. Even the best team in the world, playing in this situation, might concede four goals or even more. We are in a situation that is very complicated, very difficult and I know how they feel now in the dressing room. They are very down. But I said 'heads up' and we need to keep working."
United's best performer was Patrick Dorgu. Signed as a specialist left wing-back during Ruben Amorim's unbending days of 3-4-2-1, it's been hard to find a place for the Denmark international. As Liverpool and Anfield threatened to subsume United, the 22-year-old stood tall, winning both of his tackles and four out of five ground duels.
Maybe Pochettino can convert him into a left-back – a problem position for United that looked as problematic as ever with Lisandro Martinez forlornly chasing Bradley Barcola's shadow.
Stop Old Trafford being a talent graveyard
Despite the reputational battering this United squad have taken individually and collectively, they are not all useless players. Their deeds elsewhere suggest they are far from useless, in fact.
Matthijs de Ligt was perhaps unfortunate to be thrown into his first Premier League game in almost a year after an injury-wrecked period, but there was no excuse for the Dutchman so badly misjudging Ronald Araujo's clump forward that led to Yoro's red card. Then and when gravity got the better of the giant centre-back during the second half, only for Isak to fluff his lines, De Ligt did not look like a former Ajax, Juventus and Bayern Munich player; he looked like a competition winner.
In the 65th minute, Mason Mount came off the bench and Liverpool scored their third goal amost instantly. The peak England and Chelsea version of Mount would be a perfect Pochettino player, but he is a deeply faded memory. The Youri Tielemans who opened the scoring for Aston Villa in the Europa League final is fresh in the mind. He was a transfer coup for United, but has been largely risible since arriving in Manchester.
The work of making United something closer to the sum of their parts (this sum is cannot be 19th place and one win from 11; it's a ludicrous underperformance) begins now for Pochettino, with a midweek trip to Sporting CP in the Champions League. He must quickly identify the battered and bruised parts that can be salvaged and cast off the deadwood.
