Cardinals keep proving they’re built for chaos in thrilling walk-off win

The St. Louis Cardinals are developing a reputation that every contender eventually wants attached to it. They simply do not panic in close games.

Tuesday night’s wild 9-6 extra-innings win over the Pittsburgh Pirates felt like another example of a team that believes it is never out of a game, no matter how messy things become. And fittingly, it ended with Iván Herrera delivering the biggest swing of the night. After going hitless in his first four at-bats, Herrera crushed a three-run walk-off homer in the 10th inning at Busch Stadium, sending Cardinals fans into a frenzy and continuing one of baseball’s most underrated trends: St. Louis continues to win tight games in every possible way.

This one required power, patience and resilience all at once.

Nolan Gorman, Matthew Liberatore connection continues

For much of the night, it looked like Matthew Liberatore might steal the headlines. The left-hander was dominant early, carving through Pittsburgh’s lineup while piling up strikeouts at a rate rarely seen from the Cardinals’ contact-heavy rotation. Liberatore tied a career high in strikeouts through four innings before eventually setting a new personal best with nine punchouts.

But baseball games rarely stay simple for long. The fifth inning unraveled quickly as Pittsburgh turned a Cardinals lead into a deficit, putting pressure back on an offense that has repeatedly answered difficult moments this season.

That is where Nolan Gorman stepped in yet again. The longtime friendship between Gorman and Liberatore has become one of the more fun subplots on the Cardinals roster, and once again, Gorman delivered in a game started by his childhood friend. His towering two-run blast in the sixth inning swung momentum back toward St. Louis and continued a bizarrely consistent trend: Gorman now has 11 home runs in Liberatore starts.

That kind of timing almost feels scripted at this point.

MORE: Nick Morabito promotion signals Mets are thinking differently

Cardinals lineup keeps finding answers

The Cardinals did not rely on one big swing alone. JJ Wetherholt continued his impressive rookie campaign with an opposite-field homer that showcased elite bat control, while Alec Burleson added another insurance blast later in the game. Even after surrendering a ninth-inning lead and watching the Pirates force extras, the Cardinals still looked like the calmer team.

That composure has become a defining characteristic. St. Louis improved to 5-0 against Pittsburgh this season, but the bigger takeaway may be how these wins continue happening. The Cardinals are not dominating teams in clean, overpowering fashion every night. Instead, they are surviving stressful innings, responding immediately to momentum swings and trusting their lineup to eventually land a knockout punch.

Tuesday night, Herrera delivered it.

More MLB news:

• Nick Morabito promotion signals Mets are thinking differently
• Mets just produced the kind of win playoff teams remember
• Matthew Liberatore is still chasing the role Cardinals have waited years to see
• J.T. Ginn loses no-hit bid, shutout in heartbreaking finish vs. Angels
• White Sox rookie Sam Antonacci is suddenly becoming impossible to ignore in May