A-Rod, ex-wife open up on the Madonna affair for first time in tense moment in new doc

1 hour ago 3

Yankees legend Alex Rodriguez and his ex-wife, Cynthia Scurtis, were brutally honest about what they regret about their divorce and his rumored affair with Madonna in 2008.

In the second episode of HBO’s docuseries “Alex vs ARod,” Scurtis reflected on two instances of Rodriguez’s past infidelity and explained that the situation with Madonna was the last straw for her.

“He seemed to be extremely apologetic and not proud of his actions,” Scurtis, 52, said, as past headlines were shown about Rodriguez at a strip club and partying with other women during their marriage.

Alex Rodriguez and wife Cynthia Scurtis arrive at GQ Celebrates 2007 “Men Of The Year” at the Chateau Marmont Hotel on December 5, 2007 in Hollywood, California. FilmMagic

“We were together for about a year and I got pregnant with Ella, and then when Ella was first born [in April 2008], a very similar scenario and at that point, we got divorced.”

Scurtis did not elaborate further or name anyone.

She spoke of it as HBO showed a headline from The Post at the time suggesting Rodriguez and Madonna, who was married to Guy Ritchie at the time, were more than friends.

The couple welcomed their first daughter, Natasha, in November 2004.

Rodriguez’s first alleged time cheating on Scurtis happened in 2007 when he was spotted with a mystery woman in Toronto.

“In hindsight, I could have been a better husband, I could have been more present, I could have been more loyal, I could have been more empathetic, sympathetic, you name it,” Rodriguez said.

Scurtis filed for divorce in 2008 after six years of marriage, alleging in her filing that Rodriguez had multiple affairs and had “emotionally abandoned” her and their children.

Madonna attends a special screening of “Revolver” hosted by the Cinema Society and Piaget at the Tribeca Grand Hotel in 2007. AP

Her lawyer said at the time that Rodriguez had an “affair of the heart” with Madonna that was the “last straw,” according to People.

“That is absolutely ridiculous and not true,” Rodriguez said of the Madonna rumors at the time, telling People, “You have to have a sense of humor when it comes to this stuff.”

A representative for Madonna also denied the rumors to People, saying the singer and baseball star had the same manager, Guy Oseary, at the time.

On “Alex vs ARod,” Scurtis said Rodriguez’s “own demons” affected their marriage.

“I knew that he had his own demons and I was hoping he would get help,” she said. “And I was hoping that it could end differently than it did.

“He was really upset [about the divorce] so that affected me, but at the same time, I think I felt a sense of freedom.”

(L-R) Natasha Rodriguez, Alex Rodriguez, Ella Rodriguez and Cynthia Scurtis at the premiere of HBO Original’s “Alex vs ARod” documentary at the DGA New York Theater in New York City on Monday, November 3, 2025. ZUMAPRESS.com

Rodriguez, who did not name anyone or recall a specific scenario, addressed the New York headlines about his bad boy ways.

“First, I’ll say you can’t believe everything you read,” Rodriguez said on docuseries. “Some things are underplayed in the media and some things are overplayed and this is probably somewhere in the middle.

“It was not like we were unhappy, but we were growing apart romantically. I don’t know. Marriage is challenging.”

Rodriguez now is dating Jaclyn Cordeiro, a fitness entrepreneur.

They were first linked in October 2022 and made their relationship Instagram official two months later.

Read Entire Article